Is College Football Still College Football? NIL, Free Agency and the LSU Test
This Episode
College football now has revenue sharing, NIL markets, transfer free agency, player contracts and lawsuits over exit penalties—and LSU even tested whether former NFL players could return to college. Doc G and the Discussants ask the deeper question: when rosters become hired and transferable, what remains of the bond among athlete, university, students and alumni? This is not another argument over whether athletes should be paid. It is an examination of what professionalization may be changing about the identity and meaning of college sports.
College Football Becomes Professional
Before today's program begins, a few rules. No one will lean into anything. Nothing will be unpacked unless it arrived in a box. We will not circle back, move the needle, or tell you what something means at the end of the day. And should a talking point enter the studio unattended, it will be removed immediately. What we will do is examine the evidence, say what we actually think, disagree when necessary, and see where the discussion takes us. From Doc G Studios, Doc G and the Discussants. On sabbatical, the doctor is in.
Indeed, the doctor is in, and so is Sarah, so is the professor. And we're trying to cheer you up on Monday just a little bit. I know that's hard to do. It's almost impossible for me to cheer up completely on a Monday, but I give it my best shot. It's not Monday, it's mundane. Mundane. It really is. We established that in a previous episode sometime. I think so. And I think I said exactly the same thing. I think I actually agreed with you and then it slipped my mind totally. So we had to cover old ground yet again.
We reiterated. We reinforced. We emphasized. And on and on and on ad nauseam. Hey, I wanted to, before we get into what we're doing today, just to tell you that the Halloween show is coming up and, you know, that we take pretty seriously around here because I guess... We don't have to be in costume, do we? We don't have to be. I think we should. You could come in your costume if you'd like. That would be messy. Oh, that got Sarah. I think maybe I might come as a transgender. Let's see now. First I have to figure out which gender I am, and then switch.
You know, that would be a good idea because, you know, most of the time I think I've got a pretty good guess as to how you identify, but, you know. When you figure it out, tell me. Right, and I might, you know, just offend every listener we have. And trying to do so or you know who knows what happens with that We've got a topic today in fact for the Monday show and the Wednesday show they sort of go together we talked not too long ago about kids and gambling and We talked about basically their their on sports platforms and how easy that is to do now well you know that's sort of the end result of a lot of changes especially in the college football ranks where you know the question is are we kind of professionals now i don't even think we're kind of professionals two players left old miss not too long ago they signed nfl contracts they were then waived they were cut And then they sought to join LSU as college players once again.
A judge opened that door when they started talking about eligibility, having a fifth year eligibility. That was all tied up in COVID and they missed some time and those sorts of things. The SEC fought that, probably the premier sports conference in the country, and LSU ultimately filled its rosters without them. uh... now this is not a show about whether athletes deserve compensation They've been getting compensation in the form of tuition and travel and access to the pros one day. I mean there's been compensation.
We're talking about real compensation. They actually do get paid now though, don't they? Yeah, they can get paid. The question is for this show, what remains distinctive then about collegiate sports once the relationship becomes professional and transactional? there's been a lot of talk about this I as a staffer in the legislature had some conversations with legislators about this several conversations and my advice at the time this is probably not a good idea for many reasons but there was just no show slowing that train down it just rolled and rolled to a point now where we're actually allowing high school players to take part in this.
Just to give us a little background, let's go to the president of the NCAA, Charlie Baker, on this subject. From where you were with talking to the D1 commission and having those conversations to pros now trying to leave NFL camps to become members of college institutions again. I think it would have been naive for us to assume that if we figured out a way to create revenue sharing in the high -revenue D1 sports, that there wouldn't be schools and kids who would want to play forever. Why not, right?
The problem with that is you steal opportunities from the kids who are behind you. And that has been sort of our fundamental view on this all the way through, which is you get the opportunity that you're promised, and then you move on so that the kids who are behind you get their opportunity. And when you think about how many kids actually even come close to making an NFL team, even coming out of the power schools, I mean, it's literally 5 % to 7%, I think, of the draft eligible kids every year coming out of the power schools actually make a team?
I mean, these guys are, they're really good football players, okay? And the idea of them, if you're good enough to do that, the idea that you can then come back and play against the 93 % who are never gonna see a seat on a professional football team? and get an extra year as a result of that. I think from our point of view, first of all, that person will take space and play and time away from somebody else. And secondly, they've already played out, aged out. Finished whatever term you like and on some level as I said, I don't blame him for for wanting to do it I do blame the adults for I'm encouraging this that's exactly who I blame for this situation is the adults who are supposed to know better a long long time ago before we decided we were going to pay athletes who at the time now I'll go all the way back to the Olympics when the United States started losing at Basketball, you know a sport that we were supposed to dominate and used to be The personnel were from colleges because they were supposed to be amateurs at the Olympic level Well, then the United States started losing at basketball to other countries who were sending their professionals.
So that opened the conversation to we should send our professionals because we shouldn't be losing our national sport, by God. And so we started sending NF or NBA players. Who would lose every once in a while because they'd get a team of all -stars and send them and they wouldn't know how to play as a team and then occasionally team. Yeah, right. Yeah, what's what's that mean? You are exactly right. So I mean, it kind of goes it goes farther back than that, but that was sort of the first. Oh, I don't know.
the full realization of let's let our professionals play in amateur sports. Then just very recently a couple of guys from Ole Miss had joined NFL teams. They had brief stints as we said earlier. Lane Kiffin at Ole Miss was then chosen head coach at LSU and he wanted to give these players a chance to come back taking advantage of the rules which would let them come back for another year of eligibility because that loophole wasn't sewn shut as to say if you've ever been a professional within. You know, you are no longer eligible at this level.
And his excuse at the time, I won't say excuse or his rationale for this was that if I don't do it, the other coaches will do it. And that's just the reality. You know, if I don't have these players on my roster, some other coach will and I can't stay competitive, have no argument. with that line of reason, but it seems like when we were talking about the WNBA not too long ago, there were all kinds of people who had a problem with that line of reason. We said, you know, it'll be populated with nothing but men before too long if we allow, you know, I mean, it's really the same line of reasons.
So again, you know, I wanna put this forward too. This is not my... bread and butter, I must watch sports 24 -7 like a lot of people are. What I've chosen this subject for is basically to sort of document the decay generally of almost everything. We used to call these folks amateurs. They were compensated because they got free tuition. Not everybody on the team got free tuition or a full ride scholarship. There were players who were treated differently. They were not paid and that was an easy way to say money shouldn't really enter here.
Now it's got multiple ways to enter. So I don't know, just to kind of start us off today, if signing an NFL contract no longer ends college eligibility, is eligibility still an educational category or simply access to another labor market? Sarah, I'm thinking that this would really get under your skin because you were probably an athlete on that level who could have taken advantage of this possibly. Oh yeah. I had a full college scholarship in track if I would have stayed where I was and I moved from state to state my high school year where I moved to was completely different.
So did not take advantage of that. But I mean this is just insanity on every level as far as I'm concerned. I mean, this is going to ruin sports completely. There is not going to be professional sports or high school. Well, probably still high school because the regulations. It's all going to be like a mid -level sport because all the young kids coming up that would have transitioned into the NFL or the higher level sports. aren't going to have the experience. They're not going to have it because all the other players are either coming back down to play.
I don't know, to me it just ruins everything. You know, the whole college experience in itself and the support that people have for colleges and their college teams, that's just going to be gone. I think that's sort of how I feel about it. I think that we're going to go to a break here pretty quick. But I want to say what Rush Limbaugh said about, at least about football. And he was talking about head injuries. And this was 15, 20 years ago now, that it's already over. they just don't know it yet.
He was a huge NFL fan. In fact, he tried to buy a franchise and wasn't allowed to because of some of the comments he supposedly made that other owners didn't like. But I think that maybe that's sort of coming true now in that it used to have wide support when it was seen as a level playing field where people sort of had a place to go and prove their merit. Now I'm not so sure that with the money and the betting that's coming into it that it's going to be seen the same way going forward. So I think that we've opened a can of worms here that's going to be pretty tough to close back up again.
When we come back, the former pros are the headline. The deeper change is that current players now have contracts leverage and exit penalties when they decide to go somewhere else. You're listening to Doc G and the Discussants.
Contracts, Transfers, and Player Leverage
We'll give the Discussants a moment to regroup. In the meantime, visit Doc G and the Discussants dot com. Episodes, the shop, ways to support the show, and of course, Doc's Bright Box. Do make proper use of it. Doc G and the Discussants on sabbatical. We'll be right back. If you're looking for the official Doc G and the Discussants merchandise, you'll find it on our website dgnd .com. Browse our sabbatical collection for premium tees, hoodies, signature women's v -necks, whiskey rocks glasses, distressed ball caps, coffee mugs, and more.
Everything in the store is something we are proud to own ourselves. Take a look at docgpodcast .com or docgandthediscussance .com Your car should start when you ask it to, it should stop when you need it to, and it should not make a new noise every Tuesday. At Blue Ridge Garage, we handle brakes, batteries, oil changes, tires, and the mysterious sounds you've been ignoring for three months. Straight answers. Fair work. No drama. Blue Ridge Garage. Keep the car. Lose the problem. Insurance has become complicated enough.
Heritage Mutual Group believes coverage should still come with real conversations, straightforward answers, and people you can actually reach when something goes wrong. Whether it's home, auto, business, or life insurance, Heritage Mutual Group works to help protect what matters most without the runaround. Mornings do not need to be complicated. They need coffee. At Maple House Coffee we roast fresh, brew it strong, and leave the fancy speeches to somebody else. Hot coffee, cold brew. Fresh pastries, a comfortable chair.
That's enough. Maple House Coffee. Good coffee. No meeting required. That dog does not want to be petted. Just a little heads up before something bad happens. Move your coffee cup away from your computer. So you can have more control. Stop. You're texting your boss by mistake. Uh oh. Well, life doesn't always give you time to change the outcome. But pre -diabetes does. With early diagnosis and a few healthy changes, like managing your weight, getting active, stopping smoking, and eating healthier, you can stop pre -diabetes before it leads to type 2 diabetes.
It's easy to learn your risk. Take the one -minute test today at DoIHavePreDiabetes .org. Don't wait. You have the power to change the outcome. Visit doihabprediabetes .org today. That's doihabprediabetes .org. Brought to you by the Ad Council and its prediabetes awareness partners. or leave something for Doc in the gripe box now comes back to Doc G and the discussions on sabbatical. Welcome back. We're talking about whether college football is college football anymore. It certainly isn't. From the not very distant past, three, four years ago, things have changed quite a little bit.
I'm going to just go ahead and skip ahead a little bit and my contention is it's now just a developmental league for the pros and I don't know how popular developmental leagues are going to be. I know they're not that popular and if we get to a place where there's no more real affiliation with the university where we're just granting people occasionally for this and that. I'm not sure there's going to continue to be the dedication, the loyalty to the good old college team. Here's Nick Saban on this subject.
We need to change the calendar.
Chaos in college football starts tomorrow the portal opens there's all already been a hundred and twenty starters say they're getting in the Porter from you know big power for schools Wow so what happens if Ole Miss wins and Oregon wins So Oregon's got two coordinators trying to take guys from their team to their team, and guys from other teams to their team. And Ole Miss has got six coaches going to LSU trying to take guys to LSU from their team, but they got to play a game. Now, is that chaos?
So they're finding out that the invisible hand of the market... Adam Smith idea, economics, that you can't control everything about in market, you certainly can't predict what's going to happen except that everybody's going to act in their best interest with incomplete information. People think they have all the information they need to make a decision, but most of the time there's some other information that you're not considering that... causes you to be an heir or not make the best decision possible and that's what everybody's out there doing.
It's all about me now. You know the professor's been really quiet here and when we talked a little bit before the show I sort of said to the professor this is a subject that you know I don't have a lot of passion about. What I do have a lot of passion about is this so slow slide into idiocracy. And that's where I see this thing is on the edge of idiocracy, or maybe that's where we're at. I like that the edge of idiocracy. I think we've already fallen off that edge. Yes, the earth truly is flat. We're falling through space.
I think this all boils down to, well, obviously. than take any philosophical genius to figure this out. It's money. How is the money distributed? So it all boils down to it. Each individual involved in it, all the way from the big wigs in their suits down to the guys on the field in their respective suits and whatever. How can I get the most money out of this? How can I manipulate this to get the most money? Someone on a certain level of managerial prowess or bull? Maybe meld this in with that. In other words, pro with pro.
I can receive X number more, thousands of dollars per annum or whatever. I personally like Doc G. Well, I think he stated this. I don't want to put words in his mouth. I have no passion toward this at all. I couldn't care less. My admiration goes for people like engineers, aerodynamicists, fabricators, machinists, people that actually think and do things. I'm not interested. in watching a bunch of grown men throw around a child's ball or run down the field. He's a football hero, da -da -da -da -da -da.
Fuck me, oh, god. Anyway, no passion. It's all money. That's what it comes down to. And whether they have the pros go back and maybe they could, there could be a little stipulation here that if you're a pro returning to college, you'd have to take X number of semester hours. some crap like they could take basket weaving or doll making or something that would be commensurate with their abilities but I think I think it's money I think it's the distribution of money don't get back to you yeah oh sorry that's what I was wondering these guys that that go back that were previously in NFL and they go back What classes do they take?
I wonder about that. I don't know. Are they required classes? That would be something to look into and something I should have looked into because that's a very good question. Were they graduates? Since a lot of these guys are not graduates and they are there even under the old system purely to go to the... You, sir, do not have to take, don't trouble yourself with taking any classes. We know that's not your persuasion. Just come back here and play ball. And that's a really good point that I hadn't thought about.
How about deliberately setting this up so you go to the pro camp for a year or so, you gain a lot of knowledge on the pro level, and then it's been couched in we know you're coming back. We'll see in about a year. Spend a year with the Seahawks, get bigger, stronger, know more about the game, play against better competition, and we'll see a year after that for your final two years of eligibility. absolutely nothing at this point that would prevent that. They're just basically on a gentleman's agreement right now.
They were going to find them. Basically, this was what was going to happen if LSU was actually going to do this. There was going to be... penalties for 22 % of the defined power conference revenues. And there was going to be some other financial things that were going to happen. The FCC voted to do this, to prevent this. But they're not going to be able to prevent this without specific regulations to say so. But that flies in the face of what they're trying to do. Here's something else I want to take issue with, just sort of on our way through.
Did you notice Mr. Baker's description of the players as kids? They're kids. They're not grown men and women as people used to be at 18, 19, 20, 21 years old. We increasingly calling. college age people kids and she'll go to bed that pages that's monetary right in its and also infantilizes them in a way that, oh, they can't make these sorts of decisions for themselves, even though they've shown that they certainly can with the help of their agents. So it's sort of a strange, strange world where they are still kids.
And I heard that more and more as I was in the post -secondary education world, the legislature, these sorts of places where They were older people were being referred to as children at older and older ages. And then they would complain that they didn't have any ambition. They weren't taking on responsibility. Well, you're you're not expecting them to. If you remember, high schools used to have Latin phrases written above the door for inspiration. the doors of the bathrooms used to say men and women on them in high school.
Now it's boys and girls. And if there's any Latin anyplace, it's probably on the search warrant that some kid was handed by the principal when he walked through the door. I mean, why the hell would there be Latin on anything? It's a dead language, isn't it? You know, it's just it's changed so much in what we expect and how we expect people to grow up. Let me tell you a little about the scale of this thing and then something else that just really sticks in my craw. The College Sports Commission cleared more than $227 million in name, image, and likeness deals during the July and August 2026.
They cleared more of those deals in July and August, more than 200 deals per day they had to deal with. The colleges this is the commission that approves these deals They're looking at these deals to approve them to see if they pass whatever muster I guess they're a subject or subjecting them to Old miss is suing now. This is ridiculous as well. Ole Miss is suing LSU transfers, a couple of them, and they're seeking $550 ,000 and $400 ,000 under return agreements with 90 -day exit penalties. Wisconsin separately alleged Miami tampered with one of their players, who had a name, image, and likeness deal, and their revenue -sharing agreement, so...
They're suing individual players at this point because they're unhappy with how they separated or if they moved to another school and if they paid them and they didn't stay. Okay, I guess I... Doctor, because some attorneys are making money too. Some of the money is being distributed in that direction. Right. I guess I misunderstand how this works. I guess I was under the assumption that the players were paid But the school didn't get payment from... They've got their fingers in it, too. But they get...
I understood that they got the money. from the recognition of the player being there. Oh, get real. They get real money for this, too. I mean, it's like the professor said, and I think he boiled it down about as good as we can boil it down. It's money and everybody's got their fingers in it. Just just another little sideline point here while we're here. Elite player packages can exceed many assistant and lower level head coach salaries. Top power conference head coaches still generally earn more.
Now we're starting to see players on these teams earning more than their coaches. And when this trickles to high school with elite players, they are certainly going to make more than their coaches. So how do the coaches control their players? They are not going to be able to, is my contention. That's something we're going to talk about when we come back. The question is, if a player owes a buyout for transferring, that means they didn't, in the school's view of things, hold up their end of the bargain.
Have we admitted this is an employment situation and everything but name only? Well, I don't think it's an employment situation exactly, but I don't think it's certainly no longer our dad's football team. Idiocracy. Watch that and then you'll know what's going on. Whatever happened to players like Rudy? Yeah, Rudy. I know. I love that movie. He was happy to get his college education and just clean up in the back. I know. That's a good movie. Contracts can hold a roster together. They can also turn a university team into an annually reconstructed payroll.
You're listening to Doc G and the Discusses. The discussion continues
chool Identity and Fan Loyalty
in just a moment. While we take a break, go to docgandthediscussants .com. Meet the Discussants, catch another episode, support the show, visit the shop, or tell your favorite cast member exactly what's on your mind. Doc G and the Discussants, on sabbatical, back after this. Some of our best ideas come from the people listening. If you have a question, a comment, a show idea, or maybe someone you'd like us to interview, we'd love to hear from you. Just visit docgandthediscussance .com, click contact, and choose your favorite discussant from the drop down menu and send us your message.
Your questions, comments, or suggestions might even become part of a future episode. Thanks for listening. We appreciate it. You bought the stuff, you wanted the stuff, and now you have absolutely nowhere to put the stuff. That's where Green Lawn Storage comes in. Clean units, easy access, plenty of room for furniture, tools, boxes, and everything else you swear you're going to use again someday. Green Lawn Storage. Your stuff needs a home too. Accidents happen. Getting your vehicle repaired shouldn't add to the headache.
At Premier Collision and Auto Body, we work with all major insurance companies and handle everything from minor dents and paint repair to major collision damage. Our technicians use modern repair equipment, computerized paint matching, and manufacturer -recommended repair procedures to help get your vehicle back where it belongs, on the road. Free estimates are available Monday through Friday. Premier Collision and Auto Body. Quality repairs. Straight answers. Markets change. Economies change. Your long -term strategy shouldn't depend on panic and guesswork.
Sterling Ridge Financial provides retirement planning, investment guidance, and personalized financial strategies designed around your goals and your future. Sterling Ridge Financial. Steady planning for uncertain times.
Snakes, zombies, public speaking, the list of fears is endless. But the real danger is in your hand when you're behind the wheel. Distracted driving is what's really scary and even deadly. Eyes forward, don't drive distracted. Brought to you by NHTSA and the Ad Council. Right then, break's over. If you spent it circling back, unpacking your feelings or searching for a safe space, do try to keep up. The rest of us are getting back to the show and while you're there, have a look at docandthediscosence .com.
Episodes, The Bright Box and plenty more trouble waiting for you. You're on sabbatical with Doc G and The Discosence. The truth is more interesting than fiction and far more valuable than cliches or talking points. Back to it. You could listen to this show just for the funky bumper music. Just get down here in the studio just with the .g bumper music. I'm waiting for the professor to chime in on that one. Well, I was just thinking that maybe bumper is a rather esoteric term and maybe not everyone would know what that means.
Well, by all means then, sir. Please, enlighten our audiences to the bumper music. I think it just boils down to being a bridge between either a commercial matter or a public service announcement and then back to regular programming. It makes the transition just a little smoother, a little more pleasant. You know, that kind of crap. This announcement brought to you by the Ad Council and the professor. Just a little bit of research here. A qualitative study of eight FBS's coaches found transfers were more than 20 % of team rosters in 2023 versus about 6 % in 2019 before the world changed so much.
Coaches credited short -term roster repair but you know getting new players into you know fill spots that had emptied but warned about continuity, Vanteren leadership, and a durable culture. There's going to be a culture anymore as people are going to come in and out all the time. You know, they'll be wearing the same uniform. Remember how the coach would give the pep talk about there's no I in team, blah, blah. Well, yeah, but there is in winning and that's what you want. Right. I mean, come on.
That's how they're going to respond to. Yeah, there is in win. And so don't give me that crap. A night commission Elon survey found about 86 % of responding Division I leaders, we're talking about university presidents and provosts, viewed the portal negatively. One predicted annual turnover would weaken fan engagement outside the power conferences. I think it will weaken fan engagement even inside the power conferences. Maybe not for those betting on the game, but I know it's weakened my view of it tremendously.
That is a forecast from the leaders. It is a not yet measured fan behavior, but it's all very new. Now, just another point before we get back into our discussion. Commercialization now begins before enrollment. Ohio became the 45th state to allow this in high school. Name, image, and likeness money. get deals with shoes and posters and whatever else and do little spots for, you know, in town businesses like we, you know, see with the college kids now, kids, the college men and women now in late 2025, Michigan expanded it in 2026 with limits on collectives.
boosters and school marks. So, you know, they're saying, well, you can't use the school's mark. Who cares? At this point, NCAA rules now require incoming Division One prospects to report qualifying pre -college deals. Oh, they got to report them. The way they had it before when it was just illegal, to be taking these sorts of deals before you were a professional was the way it had the best chance of working and being enforced. At this point, there's no enforcement. They can't enforce it. They've already admitted that they should be getting paid, and so if you should be getting paid, and it's legal, you're not selling, I don't know...
cocaine on the street corner of the university or something that's illegal, then where do you draw a line intellectually? I think that that horse has left the barn at this point. And I think we're in that downward slide into idiocracy.
So this is what my dad and his friends used to say about this a long time ago. When they would hear somebody say well, what about the college kids cut all these? Universities are making these millions of dollars on the game that was viewed as a very juvenile attitude towards Sort of an apprenticeship where you were already given a college scholarship You know, yeah, you might be great, but you're not yet. And we're trying to preserve this as a environment where students and their fans and the students at the school basically compete against one another.
With that in mind, think about how things are now. Let's go to the professor. I don't like that at all. Give me money right now. Give me money. I don't want no damn atmosphere of learning and maybe molding my character. I don't want to hear any crap like that. Just maybe throw some filthy lucre in my direction. Well, you know, it's kind of been that way for a while as far as we all know, and I'm going to use this phrase kind of loosely here, the student athlete that Was the star football basketball player when they went to college Didn't really attend a whole lot of classes and if they did they were non classes The graduation rates among you know athletes or have been woefully low It's been a joke and it has been for a long time, but it was not always that way either it evolved into this.
I looked around for a way to cut out of fast times at Ridgemont High. There was a football player that Spicoli borrowed a car from that he wrecked. And a kid walked up after the car was wrecked and he saw this football player show up on the scene. He said, I thought he only flew in for games. You know, this was on the foot on the high school level. Back as far as 1982 is when I think that movie came out. You know, that talk was was going around prior to that in the 50s, 60s. Really not so much. I mean, it has evolved over a long period of time, but that attitude has has been around for longer than what we're talking about the last few years with this name, image and likeness idea.
Now, I just to add another tidbit here. when these things were debated in legislatures uh... who they like to make their point people on it was former college athletes maybe if they were lucky then they could find a former pro to come in and say how tough their life was because they didn't have this extra money in College and some of the stories that I heard a couple himself what we all used to have to live in a One bedroom apartment together and sometimes we wouldn't have any money for food or whatever and I thought to myself so that was everybody's college experience I'm sorry
But it would be like, what are you trying to do? You're trying to jerk some tears out of my eyes over, you know, everybody had it tough in college. At least you had your tuition paid for. And, you know, probably better food than the rest of us had. And, you know, you're not going to come out of this with a bunch of debt. You should come out of it with a college degree. Doubtful, you know what I mean, for a lot of them. They were there simply to do the sport. But they were getting something for representation.
presenting the school. So this leads me to a question. So do the fans love the uniform, the institution, the players, or the belief that all three belong together? I think the fans are to the same point as everybody else. It's about winning and money because they're all betting on it. Okay. I think the professors made his view known, same view. I can refer you to Sidney Sweeney and the sports betting commercial. I like that commercial. I do too. Yeah, I do. What aggravated me about it is that these stupid people are so up in arms about it because it's degradating and detrimental to women.
I think they're pretending, Sarah. I think they're pretending to be up in arms, because it's the thing to do. I don't know. Well, let's just tell the truth about it. Who do you think it is that's up in arms about this?
Nose ring, blue hair. Yeah. Yeah. Because they don't look like Sydney, and they hate any woman who does, which is the exact same thing that... Women don't like other pretty women, and especially a woman that's prettier than them a lot of the time. Yeah, that's true. Sarah, you've described that to me. And I've personally seen it that if a woman is recognized for her beauty, there's going to be automatically be attacked by other women. It just goes that way. And so that didn't surprise me at all.
And so, you know, Sydney's doesn't have any uh apologies to make no i think she does a lot of this stuff just oh i think at this point for certain yeah i mean she she knows she can get everybody's go but you know why are women basketball players for example why are they so offended by this commercial but they're not offended by men playing in but in basketball in women's basketball Please answer that question and we'll no longer need to have the show any longer. Well, then I can't better not answer that question then, huh?
Because it's... I mean, it makes no sense. Because the left has engendered perversion. For real. Upset about things they shouldn't be upset about at all and not at all upset about things that make perfect sense. and uh... on their face a ridiculous but i i don't want to go back to this question again do fans love the uniform the institution the players are the belief that all three will belong together i think you know i have this traditional view that the should be students representing their school and they should be students on the campus that they represent And they should.
Oh my god, that is so traditional. I know. He is really old. So, how many one -year rentals can a roster absorb before the alumni feel that they're cheering for a franchise that merely licenses the school colors? Because that's really kind of where we're at now. That's how I feel about it anyway. If the major programs now look professional, the clearest view of the old college model may be further down the ladder. We'll talk about that when we come back. You're listening to Doc
What Remains of the College Model?
G and the Discussance. A brief interruption, nothing more. While we're away, stop by dot g and the discussance dot com. Choose your favorite discussant, leave a question, make a comment, register a complaint, or even pay us the occasional compliment. We can handle all of it. We'll be right back. If you're wondering what Doc G and the Discussance is all about, here's the short version. Interesting people, interesting ideas, interesting topics. Politics, music, sports, leadership, business, education, technology, history.
If it's worth thinking about, it's certainly worth talking about and it's fair game. We won't chase headlines or repeat talking points. We believe the truth is far more interesting than fiction. More valuable than cliches or talking points. Learn more at docgandthediscussance .com or thediscussance .com At Oak and Iron Home Center, quality still matters. From premium mattresses and living room furniture to dining sets and home accents, Oak and Iron focuses on comfort, durability, and timeless design without the pressure and confusion of the big box stores.
Visit Oak and Iron Home Center and see the difference for yourself. Mornings do not need to be complicated. They need coffee. At Maple House Coffee, we roast fresh, brew it strong, and leave the fancy speeches to somebody else. Hot coffee, cold brew. Fresh pastries, a comfortable chair. That's enough. Maple House Coffee. Good coffee. No meeting required.
Mill Creek Hardware has the tools, supplies, and practical advice to help get the job done and done correctly. From plumbing and electrical to outdoor equipment and seasonal supplies, Mill Creek Hardware believes customer service still matters. Mill Creek Hardware. Built for people who still like doing things themselves. Most people out here think that taking care of one another is important. And most people would step up for a neighbor going through a tough time. Most people around here help out friends and family when they need it.
But the funny thing is, most of us won't look for help when we need it. If you're struggling with mental health, you should know that there are resources out there that can help. And it's okay to talk about it if you need to. One place to get started with information is loveyourmindtoday .org. Loveyourmindtoday .org offers a range of guides, instructions, and insights for dealing with difficult situations or getting through a tough time. If you're struggling with mental health, get the help you need because most people out here really care.
Visit loveyourmindtoday .org. That's loveyourmindtoday .org. brought to you by the Huntsman Mental Health Institute and the Ad Council. At the intersection of policy, politics and culture, you're on sabbatical with Doc G and the Discussants. To contact the program or email your favorite discussant, Right to doc g show studio at gmail .com. I have this team now at these places where every player is passionate about where they're playing and just gonna give their all no matter what, you know, because I wanted to go to Ohio State when I grew up and this is where I wanted to play.
You know, it is what it is. And there's independent contractors. You know, and so I look at, I talk to them a lot about that and I try to get them and I said, we understand this is not the role that you wanted right now. You know, like you came in thinking this and you're just on special teams, but I treat it more like the NFL and say, but you need to do your job because what you really want is you want to get to the NFL or you want to get a new contract here or going to Porto and get a new contract somewhere else.
Well, guess what? The best way you do that is to play really well. in the snaps that you have. So I just look at it as it is what it is. It's much more of a business now. And I try to understand how they feel about it instead of going, hey, you guys all have to buy in no matter what, you know, and, um, you know, you have a great attitude and you be excited to play. Even if you're only playing three snaps of special teams, even though you started at the place before you transfer, you're going to continue to see more upsets as this moves because because teams are going to be up and down.
You know, it's really hard. The dynasty days are over. I feel like, you know, you look at like what Alabama, what Georgia had, yeah, what Georgia was. And now and there's evidence like I've talked about with Kirby, like think before where he could collect these players and they were all there. They all wanted to go there. They bought in. And then now you have or the last two years we played great linebackers at other SEC teams. that were on George's roster and then transferred out and went and started at other SEC teams.
Those guys would have all been on the same team. That's Lane Kiffin. He was at Ole Miss and then left Ole Miss in the middle of the season basically to go to LSU for more money. and took some players with him through the porthole. And he, I think, has a very good understanding of what this is. He said, it's a business. He's treating it like NFL players are treated. And for all the criticism I have of that, I dislike that attitude toward it. I really do. But that is the game that's being played right now.
Now, further down the chain a little bit, It may still be the old college try. Balance. It isn't just essential in your sport. It's essential in life. Especially college life. It's everything you need to thrive in school, in sport, and everything in between. The key is just finding a place where you can pursue it all. Because the real beauty lies in the balance. If you want to win in every arena of college life, go D2. Make it yours. That's a commercial for Division II athletics, which is not as touched by this name, image, and likeness because they don't start with the premier athletes.
You know, Division II is not untouched by amateurism. Its athletes may still use name, image, and likeness in the portal, but it remains a useful contrast for what we've been talking about. Partial scholarships, less travel, and missed class time, campus community involvement, and no house -style Division I revenue share requirement in Division II. The money is just not. there. So as a parent of a Division II athlete, a fairly recent Division II athlete, there was scholarship, but there was a lot of work on the bus all night to get to a match.
and then on the bus all night to get back to school where there would be a exam waiting for you or a paper that needed to be turned in. Or maybe you have to go to work, which that student did as well. Work, Division II athletics, and then a very rigorous major on top of all those things. Extremely challenging, but And I don't even know how that really works into name, image, and likeness. That wasn't an option at the time. But to be a campus athlete, took a lot and still does take in many settings and even in these higher levels, a lot of dedication to do these things at the same time.
They do teach a lot of good lessons. The answer for me is not to restore uncompensated labor, but it's my contention that they've always been compensated in ways that just the general student population was not. it is to decide what institutions are selling. Are they selling education with athletics or professional entertainment wearing a university's name? I mean, where are we at now? Are we selling professional entertainment using the university's name at this point? I hope so, because that makes good business sense.
I mean, why would you want to go any other way? Yeah, and I think that that really feeds into our our thesis. Idiocracy. I mean, it is, there are no, they think that they're going to be able to control this. That's not going to be the case. Once it was admitted and it was allowed to let players get payments, Where are you going to say that the line is? I mean, for one athlete, it may be X amount of dollars, but someone else is capable of generating the three contracts for clothing for shoes. Let's grow this money machine.
It would be foolish not to. That's exactly what I'm getting at is that I see no way to rein it in at this point. And that is how I advise. Well, I don't want to rein it in. I want to make more money. And that is exactly what the market is going to do with it. There will be no reining it in. Now, we're going to talk more about that on the Wednesday show and just how we dick. ridiculous it is now getting. Ridiculous? This makes good sense. The unintended consequences, although I don't think that they were unforeseeable, I certainly foresaw them.
The C is either C, C -E -N -T -S, or since S -E -N, that has a dollar sign at the outset, so there you are. Makes good sense either way. Yeah, I don't think that You know, possible guardrails are even worth a discussion at this point. Affirm post NFL eligibility line, should we, you know, do that? Well, they won't be able to agree on that. Standardized enforcement contracts, no way. They won't be able to enforce that. They've already shown that they can't. Limited transfer windows, I don't know maybe what difference does that really make, and especially if some a student athlete, a man or a woman, notice I didn't say kids, starts crying that they didn't have the chance to make all the money they should make and of course that line of reason has already been accepted.
Transparent inducements. Should we see what's in every contract? Well, I don't know that somebody's financial arraignments are everybody's business. Real academic progress. We've been talking about that forever. That's been out the window for a long, long time. And revenue rules that do not hollow out non -revenue sports. No one cares about what happens to the non -revenue sports. What is academic? I would say that an eighth grader from 1950 would be much better versed in grammar and mathematics than a college graduate today.
If you look at the textbooks, it's pretty hard to argue otherwise. And as I've predicted on this program and publicly for policy reasons, and testified about it, I think we are on the verge of seeing our lowest test scores ever with the inception of AI and basically because young people aren't being really supervised and raised any longer. We don't care about that. Well, apparently we don't. So compensation here, some people think that corrected a real injustice. I don't think that's really the case.
I think that athletes have enjoyed compensation, if we want to use that word, that the general student population only dreamed of, unless they had academic scholarships. So I don't know about that. I think that's where we went wrong. But as more of this minor league football, takes hold which I Suggest it is now I suggest it's at the early stages, but it's just minor leagues now if we look at what's happened in other minor leagues They don't have the big crowds They don't have the interest when everybody is just rent a player for a season or two Will it continue to have the following that it has enjoyed in the past?
Well, all questions for another show, but I'm gonna go out and make a prediction that it will not. And that I, as a casual fan of my university's football team, whole lot less enthused about it these days than I used to be. So, a university can hire a better roster. It cannot purchase the meaning that made people care about that roster in the first place. That's where I'm at on it. I think we're firmly on our road to idiocracy. Well, I'm sorry to be that way. For Sarah, the professor, and Bo, who's here in the studio with us, that's going to do it for today's show.
Make sure you're with us on Wednesday because we're going to talk about point shaving, which this situation has helped to develop. You're listening to Doc G and the discussants. And so ends another hour. The arguments have been made, the questions have been asked, and what you believe from here is entirely up to you. No approved conclusion. No talking points to take home. Just one final thought. The truth is more interesting than fiction. And far more valuable than cliches or talking points. For the professor, Sarah, and everyone behind the microphones, this is Doc G and the Discussants on sabbatical.
Until next time. Bye!
Podbean