Get Your Clicks on Route 66: How Flock Cameras Watch Americans’ Road Trips
This Episode
The American road trip promises freedom, spontaneity and the open road. Flock license-plate cameras can turn each passing car into a searchable record of where it was and when. Doc G and the Discussants examine how the network works, why police value it, how innocent travel can become evidence, and what the September 2026 Senate hearing revealed about errors, misuse and security. Can a system that helps find abducted children and stolen cars operate without building a searchable travel diary for everyone else?
How Flock Cameras Track Your Travels
overflowing with talking points, where cliches are repeated until they somehow become conventional wisdom. And where every difficult question apparently comes with a list of approved answers, there remains one dangerous possibility. Think about it. Examine the evidence. Challenge the premise. Make the argument. And if the facts take you somewhere unexpected, follow them. So glad to
have you back with us. Welcome to Wednesday. This is a great time to tell you that coming up Friday is the definitive Halloween show. And I know that We are big fans of Halloween at the Doc G Studios. All of us, I think, one way or another, to some degree or another. I guess I'll speak for the professor and Sarah. Oh, thank you so much. I figured there'd probably be some issue with that, one way or another. I mean, no way would I be able to get away with saying everybody here loves Halloween. One way or another, it was going to be a problem, but apparently not.
That's good. I can't believe it got away with it. Anyway, we're going to have a real ghost story, a real ghost story that actually involves a U .S. president involved in this ghost story. Was he the ghost? Well, he is now. but he wasn't then and he was plenty scared of this thing so it's a three -part series ghost story throughout the hour so you're going to want to be here for the whole hour going to talk about halloween its origins how it went from you know being a real like sam hayne holiday to little kids and now it's from little kids to adults talk about movies, talk about stuff that actually scares the discussants.
Of course, there are some discussants here scared by nothing because they're just too darn tough. Yeah, so scary scare ourselves. It's the definitive Halloween show. It's coming up this Friday. If you're not here, you're going to miss it. So what should you do, Sarah? You should listen. You should listen. And what else should you do? Go to the website. You should go to the website. That's like and subscribe like and subscribe. Yes So what are we talking about today? It's get your clicks on route 66 Yep, more doc G. Huber.
It's not get your kicks. It's clicks on route 66 because The cameras are clicking wherever you go. The proposition here is Americans love the road trip. It still feels private and spontaneous. A national network of license plate readers, however, can turn your ordinary travel into a searchable trail. Where does useful investigation and the routine tracking begin? That's sort of what we're going to explore here. Route 66 Freedom versus FLOX Searchable Camera Network programmed road trips maybe you know kind of a thing of the past where you could just get out there and nobody would know where you're going to be as long as you're out on the road.
I mean that kind of ended a while ago anyway when you know we got cell phones people could reach out and get a hold of you. And I really like to be able to be gone. I like it when we're out of the country sometimes. I think the Bonnie and Clyde era would have been better. You could be in a little town, 15, 20 miles apart, and not know anything that was going on in the other town for what? A week. You know, you could rob a bank in one little town and they wouldn't know about it in another little town for, you know, several days.
So, you know, it made those sorts of things possible and things that are sort of impossible day and really hard to understand how they ever were possible. But, you know, you're really not out there getting kicks on Route 66 without somebody knowing about it anymore. And so is this. violation of the Constitution? I don't know, people are really starting to think about this and they're getting to be a little bit upset about it. This is the Senate Judiciary hearing, well actually, this is, he is the owner of Flock cameras.
I want to just start by asking you how surprised you were by everything that led to these changes, including that report in the Washington Post that at least 50 law enforcement officers have been charged or accused of using license plate readers for unauthorized purposes. Was it a surprise to you? Yeah, I mean, look, I think the debate we're having right now is an important one. And one of the consequences of being consequential is that a lot of people care about how your products work and how you run a business.
And I think we've been transparent. from the onset of the business that this is critical public safety infrastructure. Now, what's been a surprise is police abuse. I grew up in a city where I trusted the police and to see a single officer abuse our technology is horrible. And I think I'm really proud of the tools we built, you know, four months ago and now requiring that across the country as a mandate because I think the topic of police abuse. It's just been under discussed. And there are certainly communities who have felt this way.
And I'm proud to be a part of that kind of new chapter for law enforcement in America. I want to ask you just about the company's degree of culpability for that kind of abuse. So I saw on CNN's site a Milwaukee police officer use Flock to search the location of his romantic partner 124 times. Is that the fault of Flock in any way? Is it the fault of the police department or just the officer himself? How do you think about that issue? Yeah, I think it's a shared responsibility, right? I think we as a company develop incredibly powerful tools, right?
You know, last year we helped solve over a million crimes and I got the data from July of this year. And in July alone, we helped detect 1 ,025 missing people. And I think we all want to be safer. And the question is, how do we get there, right? How do we balance safety and privacy while holding those who have accountability, sorry, while holding those who have power? to a level of accountability. And so we're going to continue to push forward. So did anybody notice how this guy, Garrett Langley, is couching this?
Once again, they're in need of regulation. They're in need of the powers that be to make sure that this thing doesn't get out of control, even though they're putting... I noticed everything he was saying was conducive. It was very diplomatic. Right. I would call it diplomatic bullshit. Right. Like, oh, we have a marvelous... police abusing it? Oh, I'm shocked. Bull, bull, bull. Right, exactly. I mean, that is straight out of their public relations office, you know, something that he's been handed to rehearse, something that he's been handed to read word for word for certain.
That is what that is. And you are right. It is BS just to get the heat off of him for this second to get him through this interview it's one of those damage control documents that he's been handed by their guru in public relations and you know what it works most people just eat it up you know here's a conscientious guy you know I really like this guy he doesn't believe a word of what he's saying he has to say what he's saying right now in order to get him over this little hump so they can continue to do what they're doing.
So this is what happens. They take a camera image, a picture, they get your plate, your vehicle characteristics, the time and location of when you passed a particular camera, and the alert or later database That goes into a query later on that you can connect all these dots. Flock calls the expanded description a vehicle fingerprint. Plate, make, model, color, the distinguishing characteristics, a human investigator. Now this is... where I sort of call BS yet again, a human investigator still must verify what the system returns.
Right, they're not going to use the incredible power of AI data crunching to take a look at a lot of this ding. I call. BS there one camera records a passing car a shared searchable network can connect sightings across towns counties and states so you as the listener You may have passed one without even noticing it. The question is not whether you did anything wrong, the question is whether ordinary movement should become an investigative record by default, and that's what it is right now, an investigative record.
So, does travel on public road eliminate any reasonable expectation that the government will not reconstruct where you went? I don't know, Professor, how does this strike you? Well, I think obviously it's a surveillance state. I've seen on news videos on television where in some communities there's been such a backlash that they've actually taken the cameras down. But I don't know if that will endure or not. I could see the cameras going back up in a few months. Oh, yeah. Yes, I'm sorry to interrupt.
Oh, please do. No, I think you're exactly right. I think when nobody's watching. Up they go again. You know, I mean, it's now we're paying attention right now. Oh, we got in trouble. Maybe it's a year and a half. Maybe it's two years. Maybe it's six months, but up they go again. They don't go in the same places, of course, because they might be noticed, but they go someplace else. I think you're exactly right about that. I think they're just too prevalent anymore. And it was like what we talked about in the Monday show.
Police. Authorities sort of getting lazy now. They don't really go door -to -door knocking to find out about a crime. The first thing they do is check the cameras, the ring cameras, the camera down the street, the camera at the convenience store. I don't know if they really investigate crimes anymore where they don't have somebody on camera. It sounds like what we were talking about on Monday's show with the computers, this and that for the kids. and they don't have to learn anything anymore. They just rely on electronics and now it's becoming the same thing with the law enforcement community.
Yeah, I sort of wonder whether those old skills of actually proving a crime and being able to tie someone to a crime... Oh, they've atrophied. I wonder. And I think that this is yet one more step towards, hey, you know, we don't have any video so there's really nothing we can do for you. In fact, we sort of... We sort of ran into that situation not very long ago at a place where Sarah's car was involved in some minor damage. Someone had run into her car with something, we don't know what, and scratched it and put a couple dents in it.
And there was nothing that anybody was willing to do because... We couldn't see it on the videotape. So you're just out of luck. And that's basically what we expected would happen anyway. In today's day and age, nobody's really going to go out of their way, even though there's probably, what, $1 ,000 worth of damage that you'll just have to eat that. Does travel on public road eliminate any reasonable expectation the government will not reconstruct where you went? I kind of think that there's not a reasonable expectation.
that the government's not going to know exactly where you went and that's a shame and I think people should get a little bit upset about it. Don't you think they know anyway? I don't know how they know unless you know we're talking about I have my phone. I have my smartwatches. You're right about that. I have my meta glasses. You're right about that. All of that. Yes, you are. And then there's a computer in your car. Now you've made the conversation bigger. I'm sorry. Why don't you keep your opinions to yourself so we can keep this thing contained somehow.
A camera belongs to one town. The search may not stop at the town line. After the break, who can see your trip? You're listening to Doc G and the Discussants. At the intersection of policy, politics, and culture, you're on Symbatical with Doc G and the Discussants. Let's step aside for a few brief messages. If you're wondering what Doc G and the Discussants is all about, here's the short version. Interesting people, interesting ideas, interesting topics. Politics, music, sports, leadership, business, education, technology, history.
If it's worth thinking about, it's certainly worth talking about and it's fair game. We won't chase headlines or repeat talking points. We believe the truth is far more interesting than fiction. More valuable than cliches or talking points. Learn more at docgandthediscussance .com or thediscussance .com. Accidents happen. Getting your vehicle repaired shouldn't add to the headache. At Premier Collision and Auto Body, we work with all major insurance companies and handle everything from minor dents and paint repair to major collision damage.
Our technicians use modern repair equipment, computerized paint matching, and manufacturer -recommended repair procedures to help get your vehicle back where it belongs, on the road. Free estimates are available Monday through Friday. Premier Collision and Auto Body. Quality repairs, straight answers, or buying a home, growing a business, planning for retirement, or simply looking for a better place to manage your everyday finances. Our local team is here to help. With convenient online and mobile banking, competitive lending options, and people you can actually talk to, Ozark Regional Bank combines modern banking with hometown service.
Stop by one of our convenient locations or learn more today.
When your heating or cooling system quits, you don't want a sales pitch. You want it fixed. Call Hartman Heating and Cooling. Our experienced technicians service all major brands and offer repair, replacement, seasonal maintenance, and indoor air quality solutions for homes and businesses. And with 24 -hour emergency service, Hartman is there when you need us most. Call today and ask about our seasonal system check. Hartman Heating and Cooling. Comfort you can count on.
This message is for Shana, my mom who just finished her high school diploma. I wanted to say I'm so proud of you for finishing school. You told me it's never too late to achieve your dreams. I hope to make you as proud as you have made me. When you graduate, they graduate. Finish your high school diploma for you and for them. Visit finishyourdiploma .org to find free and supportive adult education centers near you. Brought to you by the Dollar General Literacy Foundation and the Ad Council. As veterans, we're no strangers to helping others.
That's what we were taught, service before self. But we do have one question for the veterans listening. When was the last time you reached out for help? If you or someone you know needs resources, whether it's for stress, finances, employment or mental health, don't wait. Reach out. Find more information at va .gov slash reach. That's va .gov slash reach. Brought to you by the United States Department of Veterans Affairs and the Ad Council. Right then, break's over. If you spent it circling back, unpacking your feelings or searching for a safe space, do try to keep up.
The rest of us are getting back to the show and while you're there have a look at docandthediscosence .com. Episodes, the gripe box and plenty more trouble waiting for you. You're on sabbatical with Doc G and The Discosence. The truth is more interesting than fiction and far more valuable than cliches or talking points. Back to it. Welcome back.
Who Can See Your Trip? The Surveillance
We're talking about flock cameras, where they're at. There are thousands of them nationwide, and what that might mean to you and your trip down Route 66. I think that nostalgia is now truly just that. It's just a memory now because, now, you know, it's kind of hard to find Route 66 anymore. Yeah, it doesn't exist very much. Well, not really. Hey man, hey, hey dude, hey, clock off man, clock you in the left ear. Route 66 and wherever else you might be driving. This is a good opportunity to again mention I'm excited about this show the definitive Doc G in Discussance Halloween show coming up Friday where we have an actual ghost story an actual ghost story that is this ghost is uh...
blamed for at least one death uh... some other crazy things going on a u .s. president involved in this ghost story along with the discussions their uh... favorite costumes favorite halloween movies talking about the history of halloween we've got a ghost you're hyping this show so much i don't know if you're going to be able to back it up he loves halloween doesn't he we are going to have the definitive halloween story I'm not kidding. Well, it better be. It better be now. At this point, it probably better be, because it has been hyped a little bit.
You better get on that. So, hey, we're talking about flock cameras. And this is Senator Hawley at a September 23rd hearing at the Senate Judiciary Committee. Practically every state in the union now has them, hundreds of thousands of them, recording billions of images every single month. And the question is, where are all of these images going? Who is using them? What are the privacy protections for them? How do we make sure that this kind of surveillance is consonant with the Constitution of the United States?
You know, there's many players in this industry, but there's one name that really stands out above the rest, and that is Flock. If you haven't heard of Flock, all I have to say is Flock's probably heard of you. In fact, the truth is you have probably been scanned and surveilled and tagged and logged multiple times this week. alone. And that's because Flock, by its own admission and its own statistics, maintains a network of 120 ,000 individual cameras in 49 states all across this country. It estimates that those cameras scan and then generate some 20 billion images, that's with a B, 20 billion images of individuals in their cars or on their motorcycles or other vehicles, every single month 20 billion images every single and we wondered when we did the AI data center show just a while back where we talked about the scale of these data you talk about just billions of images that's one that's one company putting these things then you have you know other companies putting billions and billions of images up, plus everyone using AI, plus everybody using computing, plus everybody gaming, plus everybody's, you know, you name it, there's data.
This is why these things are so huge. If you're interested in that question, you might go back and find that show because we've sort of explained why they're so big, where they're at, and some of the problems with them. But agencies, they control their own cameras and sharing settings, but cross -jurisdiction searches can reach far beyond the place that bought the equipment. presented to the Senate, if we just heard Senator Hawley, 120 ,000 flock cameras nationwide. That's a lot of cameras on polls where they're put in.
And that's really probably not the total of camera network that's being used when we talk about ring cameras and the rest of this stuff. So speed matters, of course, when a child is missing. Let's talk about the good things here. Okay, a violent suspect is fleeing or a stolen vehicle is moving across jurisdictions You've got access to a lot of information there. So the governance question comes down to this. Who then authorizes a search? What crime level qualifies to go and look at all this data?
Does another agency need to issue a warrant, a case number, or merely a stated reason? So if we're going to use these things for the good things it says, And FLOX June 2026 policy moved the default retention period from 30 days. They used to keep this for 30 days to seven, I guess, to placate, you know, those who are starting to criticize local law or policy may differ, but data downloaded into a case can outlive the default window. Right, because it's all still downloaded. It's still there. It did not go away.
But it did its job in placating people. So, you know, there are some good things they're probably finding more stolen cars if a kid goes missing you're kind of know where you didn't have pictures before like we were saying this is just a bad thing there's probably some good things does the good outweigh the bad is the question the biggest question I have on this and I don't know if it's a question flock cameras themselves alone don't have facial recognition They have to use that in conjunction with another software.
So when they state that they're using flock cameras to help find kids, they're looking for the cars that the kids might have been put into or whatever. They're not actually really looking. facial recognition software because that would be different. I don't trust them. I don't trust them at all to say that. I just do not trust them. I think that when they need to bring whatever technology to bear to find what they want to find I think that they'll bring it to bear. Might not do it right there. Might go down the hall and use another computer or whatever.
I just don't. So let's go back to that. We were talking, I think, during the break. I don't think we did it on the air. We were talking about an episode of Top Gear, where the folks on Top Gear, it's Jeremy Clarkson and Brian May. No, not Brian May. His last name is May, but it's not Brian May. Anyway, these guys have adventures in old automobiles and they drive the latest automobile. It's funny. We like it. It's a it's a Brit show. They tried to translate it to the United States and put some it didn't work at all.
It was it was pathetic. That version. But anyway, they were in China just driving around an adventure in China like they do. And every time they passed a pole, every time they pass an underpass. Every time they pass any kind of sign, it looked like Christmas. All these flashes going on, and it's cameras. And they're not at all shy about saying they're using facial recognition. Instead, you know, the Chinese sort of pioneered that technology. They want to know where everybody is, wherever they are, all the time.
So why do we believe that these companies will stop at not using facial recognition? And why is it any better or any worse? Professor, what do you think? I think privacy is long gone, actually. I don't know how anyone maintains an illusion of privacy.
So what more can I say? I mean, we're not going to lose it. It's gone already. I think that it is gone. And I think privacy, just to... maybe go one step further. I think it's very important for people to have privacy and I think young people... I'm being watched right now probably with some kind of a heat sensitive device from a satellite above me or something like, look at that guy sitting down in there talking. I'd like to say take off that tin foil hat you're wearing, but I'm not going to do that because I think it's completely possible.
I know it's possible for them to watch you through a heat signature if they so choose to do that. I think it is time for people to really start looking at this because... Do you remember, it wasn't very long ago, that if anything like this came up, the reference was to big brothers watching me. How far are we going to let the surveillance state go? Well, I think we've let it go almost as far as it's going to go. And my earlier point about privacy being important to people, I don't think kids know what privacy is.
They put everything online from the time they're small now. This is another outcropping of the indoctrination instead of education in our school system. I think this is an outcropping of it. Yeah, I think that everybody expects that they'll have basically zero privacy. But then, then when something occurs like, oh, they've published the nude pictures that I sent my boyfriend three months ago. That's somehow someone else's fault other than the person who took the pictures, shared the pictures online.
It used to be, and I hate to start a sentence with that phrase, it used to be that if you were that irresponsible with your own information, no one had much sympathy for what happened to you afterwards. That sort of material only exists. if you allow it to exist. And I don't think that that's changed. Unless they're taking pictures of you in changing rooms now, which happens. I mean, it's... That does happen. Right, it does happen. But I don't think it's legal. Well, I know it's not legal. I mean, it's just individuals doing that kind of thing.
But... You know, now we have a whole generation of people who are sharing naked pictures of themselves and not just kids. Stupid adults taking pictures of themselves and sending pictures of themselves through their cell phones to each other. And they expect that the outcome's going to be anything other than bad? I mean, whew! Well, if we have all this surveillance, then how is any crime ever committed? If we're watched everywhere and they see us everywhere, then how come all the crimes are not? Solved well, I think that part of the crime is way down It's way down and maybe part of the reason why is because there's so much surveillance going on plus This administration has made no bones about we are going to throw bad guys in jail.
They get the message So, you know crime has gone down, but I also think it you know these Cameras and the existence of these cameras is making a difference because as we Talked about a little bit earlier whenever a crime goes down You're watching a crime show the first thing they do is go find camera footage of and most of the time it exists What about all these? What about the guy from Butler that attempted the assassination on Trump or whatever? We can't find anything out about him. Where's the surveillance on him?
don't wouldn't know how to answer that question is at all is is seven days short enough would you permit emergency searching first and judicial review afterward I don't know and this all feels wrong and in a place where we need to be very careful but at the same time if we're using this to find a child who's been kidnapped How are you going to argue against it? The system can find the right car quickly. It can also make the wrong car look like evidence. There's been some people who have been in nightmare scenarios over this technology.
Next, the air and abuse test. You're listening to Doc G and the Discussants.
The discussion continues in just a moment. While we take a break, go to Doc G and the Discussants dot com. Meet the Discussants, catch another episode, support the show, visit the shop, or tell your favorite cast member exactly what's on your mind. Doc G and the Discussants on sabbatical back after this. Every successful show has great sponsors. If you'd like to introduce your business to our audience, we'd like you to consider our tremendous sponsorship opportunities. Choose from general admission, mezzanine, front row floor, backstage pass, or executive producer.
Every sponsorship includes recognition on the show, founding sponsor status, preferred advertising rates, and additional benefits based on your sponsorship level. You'll find complete details at dgnd .com or docgandthediscussance .com Your car should start when you ask it to, it should stop when you need it to, and it should not make a new noise every Tuesday. At Blue Ridge Garage, we handle brakes, batteries, oil changes, tires, and the mysterious sounds you've been ignoring for three months. Straight answers, fair work, no drama.
Blue Ridge Garage. Keep the car. Lose the problem. Security isn't about reacting. It's about knowing. Deep Blue Home Security. gives you full visibility doors windows motion all of it where you need it quiet system immediate alerts and no unnecessary noise unless that noise matters deep blue home security you don't think about it because it's already handled At Oak and Iron Home Center, quality still matters. From premium mattresses and living room furniture to dining sets and home accents, Oak and Iron focuses on comfort, durability, and timeless design without the pressure and confusion of the big box stores.
Visit Oak and Iron Home Center and see the difference for yourself. Real talent is defined by what people can do, not where they learn to do it. So by stopping at the education section of a resume, you might throw away the perfect hire. You might miss someone who has valuable skills to offer, to help your business thrive right now and in the future. Because the truth is this. Skills First hiring helps you see talent others miss. Like more than 70 million stars, skilled through alternative routes.
When you let their story unfold, you gain a competitive advantage. Because hiring managers who start with skills are 60 % more likely to find a successful hire. See the real person. Complete. See what others miss. Hire skills first. Learn why it's a competitive advantage at tearthepaperceiling .org. Brought to you by Opportunity at Work and the Ad Council. And we're back. Remember, the program doesn't end when the microphones go off. Visit docg and thediscussants .com. Comment on the show, suggest a subject, visit the shop, support the program, or leave something for Doc in the gripe box.
Now, back to Doc G and the Discussants on sabbatical. We're talking about
False Accusations and Lost Freedom
flock cameras and some of the potential problems we see, but also some of the ways that these things have helped in the past. There have been some nightmare scenarios where people have been falsely accused and you would think that that would be kind of hard to do because, you know, you've got all these pictures, you've got all this video, you should have definitive evidence of what has happened. Well, not all the time. Lindsay Isaacs could tell you about that firsthand. I came here today because I want you to understand that surveillance technology does not exist in a vacuum.
Information collected by technology can become part of an investigation that affects a real human being. In my case, a flock camera captured my vehicle a few miles from the scene of a terrible crash. That piece of information became part of an investigation that ultimately led to my arrest on three counts of vehicular homicide and 13 days in jail for a crash I had nothing to do with. She was nowhere close to that scene. She told senators at Senator Hawley's hearing that a camera sighted miles from a fatal crash became part of an investigation that led to three vehicular homicide charges and 13 days in jail for her.
A later investigation concluded authorities had targeted the wrong vehicle, of course. The camera produced the data, the investigators interpreted it and acted. The distinction is precisely why human verification and evidentiary rules matter. So they just, they insisted, they came to her house, they looked at her car, they said, hey, this car was involved in a multiple... homicide event. Her parents were dumbfounded as they watched them put this thing on a tow truck and all the damage that they said was on the vehicle was not on the vehicle.
They put her in handcuffs. downtown she went for 13 days and they insisted that she was the one who did this thing and it took a lot to unwind it. So did that did it misread her license plate? No it matched the make of her car to make of a car that was involved and because no one's paying attention because as we said a little earlier that would take too much work and you actually actual police work as we talked about earlier that was the result charged with three vehicular counts of homicide and 13 days in jail.
So, you know, not only is that a problem, here's some mission creep for you. EFF records showed a Texas sheriff's office ran abortion -related searches, including one across... 83 ,345 cameras in 6 ,809 networks. The sheriff in Flock had initially described the matters as a mission person search. And they were looking for a missing person using this, but that wasn't what it was. They were trying to track abortion activity and using that as an excuse to do so. So, you know, we're already seeing this thing become abused in some really scary ways.
And so what are we going to do about this? Discussance? I mean, They're watching us and they're throwing our countrymen in jail over poor information or no information or information that has not passed any sort of test whatsoever obviously. Well I know my son's a police officer. He does use the flock cameras but according to him If they go in to search for something, they have to sign in, log in, give the reason of what they're looking for. And if it's misused, they are dismissed. Sure, and I could see where that could be used but now let me repeat what just happened here They were using these cameras to track abortion activity when they said they were using it for a missing person That's how easy it is to abuse and there's always bad apples, right?
And I think probably way more than we even want to know about we heard not too long ago of some cop tracking his ex -girlfriend using these things. I mean, I can't even believe how stupid that is, given the power of these things, that someone would actually use these things to do it, given the scrutiny they're under. Let's go to the professor. The professor is a guy who likes to use cameras. Yes, he does. Yeah, he does. We established that in the Ozark Festival shows. He's very handy. How do you feel about these cameras, sir?
Not good, but it's just another sign of where we are as a society. I'm not expecting things to improve. Maybe as a small -time example, I went into Walmart yesterday to get a car battery and my caveman way of approaching it was I simply measured the battery in the car that was on the way to failing and got the dimensions. I thought, I'll just go to Walmart and I'll take a plastic ruler in there with me. and I'll measure a battery on the shelf and pick one that's the same dimensions and it's the same or more cold cranking amps blah blah blah but as I walked in the store I thought well I'm going to be on camera and when I leave the store they'll probably think I'm shoplifting the ruler I brought in a little plastic one foot long ruler so as I walked in the store I actually held the ruler up plainly up high in front of me as I walked in I could see myself on screen holding that ruler I thought, OK, this is my evidence for later when I exit and they say, oh, you've got to pay for this ruler.
I can't let you shoplift it and say, nope, check the security video and you'll see that I carried this in. But anyway, that's just one example of cameras and foolishness. And I agree with what you said. It's stupid. I'll add to it on the police work regarding that example you gave. It's lazy. It's negligent. And it seems like that's permeating society. It stems back from the educational system right up to where these people who've gone through the system are now holding positions of responsibility.
They're stupid, they're lazy, they're heedless, they're negligent. I know there'll be a few conscientious people sprinkled in there, here and there, but not enough of them to count on for things to go properly. Hence... The lady's 13 days in jail and the false accusation and all that. That's kind of where I stand. It's a futility thing. It's not going to get any better. So that's where we are. We're headed downhill. Circling the drain. Yeah, it's it's part of the idiocracy thing that we're talking about in that It is it's it's it's becoming very very easy to rely on a computer or a camera or to say well, you know, I can't really be held responsible for that because Chat GPT told me to do so, you know getting back to the log, you know But as we demonstrated, a search log helps only if the names, plates, reasons, and outcomes remain visible, and somebody independent actually reviews them.
You know, if you look at those very close, you're going to see. Let's just put this a little easier. Back in radio days, we all used to have to keep a log of the operating and the transmitter log. And I knew several broadcasters, because that was part of your broadcast license at the time. Gosh, what was that? We were all driving a horse and buggy at that time to the station. With broadcast endorsements. Right, and you had to take the actual readings on the transmitter. Well, those of us who were conscientious did so on regular intervals because we realized that would be the only way to trace problems if they in fact occurred.
But then there were others who would take all their readings at the end of their shift. Just make them up and put them down. That's going on. You know what's going on because we've watched those kinds of things happen. So which failures worry you the most? A false match, an officer abusing access, another jurisdiction conducting the search, you know, one that doesn't have anything to do with you or what you're doing, a lawful system quietly expanding into new purposes? I think for me, I'm kind of worried about all those things.
Is there anything in particular? Go ahead. Well, I agree. I don't know if I'm... I don't know. Maybe I'm beyond worrying. Maybe I'm to the point of resignation. But yeah, I think of all those things that you just mentioned that you said you're worried about. But I may be at a point where I think, well, that's the way they are. Now I'm just resigned to it. It's sad. It hurts the quality of life. But... It's where we are.
I don't know. This is something that I think is really important. I'm never going to say that it's not important to find a lost child. I'm never going to say that it's not important to be able to track down a murderer or someone who's stolen something valuable or any kind of crime. Is it more important to be able to do this or is liberty the main pillar on which this country was founded more important? That used to be really important to people. It's still very important to me. My privacy is extremely important to me.
You know, there are things that... I'm in public doing, there's things in private that I want to stay private, my viewing habits, just basically my day -to -day existence. I don't want to discuss that with everybody. a dying breed of person that doesn't want to put everything on Facebook because other people have but I think that it's important to your psychological well -being to have something to yourself and to have a piece of this world that you own and not everybody invades and so for my part I'm going to say that I think liberty is more important than these things.
I'm sure there's somebody who wants to argue with that because... Psychological well -being is dissipating into the ether. I just wanted to add that. We all have mental health issues, right? Right. I guess here's the crux to the argument when we get back. If the Cameron network is staying, what rules would make it compatible with freedom? Americans... associate the road with and just freedom in general because I think that's where we're at. I mean I think we're really on the cusp of losing it and certainly losing some liberty with these sorts of issues.
This is concerning to Senator Hawley and the Senate Judiciary Committee as well as it is to the discussants. You're listening to Doc G and the Discussants on sabbatical. Some of our best ideas come from the people listening. If you have a question, a comment, a show idea, or maybe someone you'd like us to interview, we'd love to hear from you. Just visit docgandthediscussance .com. Click contact and choose your favorite discussant from the drop -down menu and send us your message. Your questions, comments, or suggestions might even become part of a future episode.
Thanks for listening. We appreciate it. Markets change. Economies change. Your long -term strategy shouldn't depend on panic and guesswork. Sterling Ridge Financial provides retirement planning. investment guidance, and personalized financial strategies designed around your goals and your future. Sterling Ridge Financial. Steady planning for uncertain times. You bought the stuff, you wanted the stuff, and now you have absolutely nowhere to put the stuff. That's where Green Lawn Storage comes in.
Clean units, easy access, plenty of room for furniture, tools, boxes. And everything else you swear you're going to use again someday. Green lawn storage. Your stuff needs a home, too. Don't you wish your life came with a warning app? Stop. That dog does not want to be petted. Just a little heads up before something bad happens. Move your coffee cup away from your computer. No, no, no, no. So you can have more control. Stop. You're texting your boss by mistake. Uh -oh. Well, life doesn't always give you time to change the outcome, but pre -diabetes does.
With early diagnosis and a few healthy changes like managing your weight, getting active, stopping smoking, and eating healthier, you can stop pre -diabetes before it leads to type 2 diabetes. It's easy to learn your risk. Take the one -minute test today at DoIHavePreDiabetes .org. Warning, the cap is loose on that catch -up. Don't wait. You have the power to change the outcome. Visit doihabprediabetes .org today. That's doihabprediabetes .org. Brought to you by the Ad Council and its prediabetes awareness partners.
If you have need for an emotional support animal, well, you're in the wrong place. You're on sabbatical with Doc G and the discussants at the intersection of policy, politics, and culture. Have a question for your favorite discussant. Well, please visit us on the World Wide Web at thediscusses .com. The Doctor is in. I have to
Can We Protect Road-Trip Freedom?
say, when I was thinking about this show and the freedom of Route 66, I was thinking about Chevy Chase and... Beverly D 'Angelo and the kids of them hitting the road with, you know, vacation. And as Chevy is traversing the country in the family truckster, he ends up in the middle of the desert with the truckster completely broken down after he jumped a sand dune and, you know, had to track through the desert and try to find a way home, got taken advantage of by a garage out there for every bit of his money just to fix it up to get it back on the road.
And I was thinking to myself, You know, this idea of just getting lost somewhere in the country, which Americans used to cherish. Is it over with? It kind of thinks so if we're to believe Senator Hawley, and I do believe him about all the images they have of me. He has no reason to cook that up in any way, but it also could have helped. porch heavy at the same time. He may not have been wandering the desert so long in search of water and rescue if they had known where he went off the road. So I see it kind of both ways.
But I my gut on this is that we need to stop it now and just say we're better off without some of the benefits. I know what I'm going to get you for Christmas. An anti -surveillance hoodie. An anti -surveillance hoodie? You're going to have to tell me about this. I didn't even know such a thing existed. Go ahead. Let's hear about it. Maybe I do want this. They hide you from the cameras. They can't read it. They have the same little thing. They have little stickers for your car too that it messes with the cameras.
Merry Christmas to you. An anti -surveillance. That's like a Harry Potter invisibility cloak. It is. So I'm getting a Harry Potter invisibility cloak for Christmas. Here's my policy test here.
Again, I'm not so sure I want any of this, but I'm going to sort of make it as good as I can make it. So the test is serious crime purpose limits. It's just for very serious crimes. We define that in law. A warrant for historical route searches. You know, you're going to have a search warrant for a judge to go after the route of somebody, you know, where they're driving, where they're going. Emergency exception with prompt review. I mean, if it's a absolute emergency, maybe there's an exception for that.
Maybe a DA can actually say we need this information. Short retention periods, you know, not very long. We're going to get rid of the data after it's recorded, let's say seven days, but then I might not be able to solve an old crime. Human confirmation before a stop. We're not going to let AI interpret this. A complete audit trail of where these things came from, where this information came from, and serious consequences for misuse. Because here's the public contract, a published camera location so people know where they're at.
The vendor terms. who's allowed to do this and what they're allowed to do in terms of retention of data, sharing this with their partners, the search categories that they're allowed to undertake, audit results, and the annual proof of investigative value. I mean, I'm just trying to see what law might do here to keep us somewhat on the straight and narrow. No secret expansion. A city that bought plate readers should not drift into facial recognition as we've talked to several talked about several times which I also said I do not trust whatsoever that that won't happen predictive policing or annual proof of investigative value I don't know name one safeguard without which you would reject the system or explain why no safeguard is sufficient Let's start with you, Sarah.
What do you think? I don't know. The biggest thing that I think is they're inaccurate a lot. I mean, they're wrong a lot. They'll say a C is a G or a B is a R. I mean, so they're wrong a lot. Well, yeah, we can go back to Lindsay Isaac's case that we talked about earlier. She was in jail for 13 days charged with murder. Right. That you have to have people do the investigation you can't just go by that But I do think it is headed towards like like on minority report where it was predictive sure where they were going to Stop the crime before it had a big cities doing that.
I think that's I mean, I think we're just I think we're headed there. Yeah, I think so, too. This is this is what a camera can actually do. The power of these cameras. A flock makes a lot of different cameras. They make the condor camera. They make the older Falcon ones, which are LPRs. And I think we'll be talking about that a little bit more today, because that also kind of defines what A .I. is like how it's being used and stuff. But in in this case, they were pan tilt zoom cameras. So they would actually follow people.
And in some cases, I was able to go back. Week and read what was some on someone's phone screen as they were texting somebody walking under the camera You could read what someone had on their on their phone. Well, they were just walking by the camera Yes, and you were able to just do this by just your own knowledge You said clicking a link and and getting in yeah I could actually send like I would have been able to send the link to you and you would have just clicked it and browse this interface from your phone.
Again, that's Senator Hawley and the Senate Judiciary Committee talking with people about this technology and that is pretty scary that, you know, what else can they do? That's what we know they can do. They can find out what's on your phone just by sort of being close to it. Let's let the professor make, I don't know, a prediction. What do you think? Are we going to stop this? Should we stop it? Good or bad? I mean, this is really tough for me because I can see the good it does. I mean, it does do some good.
But I also really value my liberty, privacy, and my ability to be an individual. And I think that really hurts that. It does. I think it's, just to repeat myself, it's going downhill. Nothing's going to improve. As I said earlier in the show, they might take down some cameras because of public protest, but they'll go right back up again, maybe a block away from where they were formerly. I mean, code enforcement tells me I have to keep my grass a certain length. I own the grass, I own the land, and yet here's a committee in town government that's dictating what I might do on my private property.
As I said earlier, I'm being watched now from outer space with a heat -sensitive camera of sorts.
I think I'd rather have been alive like 1900, 1903, when we transitioned into manned flight. I think that was a more exhilarating concept than this so -called high -tech foolishness. I think this is dehumanizing and it's brave new world crap. Makes you glad you have a finite end on your lifespan. It seems to me like there's some things really now converging like maybe never before this AI idea this idea of surveillance constantly and this idea of it consuming more and more energy all at the same time and it thinking faster than humans can keep up with it and it seems that no one really wants to say that's a bridge too far there are some people who are now you know Bernie Sanders among them which makes me wonder This must be wrong if he says so, but I do think that, you know, these are really worth thinking about.
But I also know that it's probably time to take some action on preserving personal liberty, personal privacy. That's what this country has always been about, and that is... Of course, we have to stay ahead of China, blah, blah, blah. That's what bothers me. I think we are behind it. I think we are behind them in their surveillance state, but quickly catching up. So, you know, I'm glad to be behind them in that respect, but I think we are quickly catching up and I don't think near enough people are worried about it.
I really don't think so. I mean, I'm very willing to talk to my senators and representatives about these issues because They really do concern me, and I think it is really anti -American. I really do. I agree with all that. I think you're being idealistic, though, in thinking that speaking with officials is going to have any effect. I don't have any illusion that it might not, but that's the best I can do. Besides this program and say that I think that this is something where a lot of us need to draw a line.
your senator call your representative column and say i think this needs to be stopped because Those things do make a difference when you call. They know that if you're putting them in office, and believe you me, they love their offices and their perks that go along with them. I got a call from a constituent and he's concerned about all this. They don't care about one, but they care about a lot. And if they start hearing from people on a consistent basis about, I am concerned about this and this is what I want you to do about it.
They will pay attention. Now, one, you're right. You just call with a random gripe. They're probably going to hand you off to a staffer. But if they hear from 10 people, 20 people, 30 people, now they know they've got an issue out there. And they do have an issue out there. Let me, you know, before we get out of here today, let me direct you towards the definitive Halloween program once again. What? Yes, the definitive Halloween program. It's coming up on Friday. It's Doc G in the Discussance, and we're going to be doing...
Yeah, it's All Hallows Eve, where we will be talking about our favorite ghost stories, favorite movies, favorite parties, favorite costumes, the history of Halloween, and we have a real ghost story for you. So, you know, you're going to want to be here for that show. You're also going to want to be around next week when we have... a whole big bunch of new topics coming your way. Never miss an episode. What do we do to make sure we never miss an episode, Sarah? Like and subscribe. Like and subscribe.
Hey, we finally found a way to do it that at least entertains me anyway. Thanks for listening. The show is in the books, but the arguments aren't over. The headlines will change. The talking points will be rewritten, and tomorrow somebody will confidently explain why yesterday never happened. We'll be paying attention. Keep the show going at docgandthediscussants .com. Catch every episode, send something to Doc's gripe box, ask a discussant, visit the store, and support the show. That's docgandthediscussants .com.
The truth is more interesting than fiction and far more valuable than cliches or talking points. Until next time, you've been on sabbatical with Doc G and the Discuss ads.
Podbean