Your Child Is Talking to AI. Who Is Listening?
This Episode
Your child may begin with homework—but what happens when an AI tutor becomes a confidant? Doc G and the Discussants examine how schools and technology companies collect, retain and govern student conversations; why companion chatbots are different from supervised classroom tools; and what parents, teachers and districts should demand before a child logs in. The question is no longer whether students will use AI. It is who hears what they say, who keeps it and who answers when the system causes harm.
AI at School: Who’s Responsible?
There is, of course, an easier way to make a program like this. Choose a side, memorize the approved vocabulary, repeat the proper talking points, and under no circumstances ask an inconvenient question. We considered that approach. Briefly. Instead, there will be facts to examine, assumptions to challenge, arguments to make, and absolutely no requirement that everyone arrive at the same conclusion. Imagine that. This is Doc G and the Discussants. on sabbatical the doctor is in so welcome into the program today full disclosure this is this would be the second time around for this program for us yeah it's really not that funny at least not to the discussions and not to me either we even did this entire program The discussions are disgusted.
Yeah, they are. I'm disgusted that we did this entire program and then it disappeared into computer land ether, I guess. So it should be the press program ever because we've done it all before. What was it I said? I don't remember. I don't remember what you said. Oh, well. Just the minute I say that we've rehearsed the program, then I don't remember anything I've said. Excellent. Did you say something? Yeah. Why? Why has it got to be like that? I want to remind you, once again, I think we remind you Monday that Friday is the definitive Halloween show.
for one, am excited about. I think the discussants are tired of hearing it from me. Well, I think that was probably all removed from the first episode. The pre -recording of the recording. Could have been. Do we have to dress up? Do we have to come in costume? Yes, sir. I will be in costume, just for moral support. I think I'm going to come as an extreme left -winger, a communist. That sounds great. Blue hair and all. It would be a horror. Yeah, I don't think it'll be hard to find a costume, or at least won't be hard to.
I don't know, conceptualize the costume. I've got to dye my hair blue, get a nose ring in, and get me a protest sign. So anyway, don't forget, it is the Definitive Halloween Show, Dr. G and the Discussants. We're going to be talking about our favorite Halloween stuff, and we have a real ghost story for you, so make sure that you're with us today. We're talking about AI and your kid. You know, your child is talking to AI quite a little bit. Whether you know it or not, they're talking to AI both at school and at home at late night in their room when you don't know what they're doing, which you should know.
You should know what your kid's doing. We'll get to that in a little bit. So if your child asks AI for help with their math and then a little later the child says to the AI bot that My parents are fighting, don't tell anyone. How many people are party to that conversation these days? Maybe more than we think. The company that has the chat bot, they certainly have a record of that conversation. How many people are behind that chat bot? And what if they said something to him that was extremely personal or very dangerous?
Is there any obligation for the chat box to talk to other adults about what they've heard? These are all things we want to explore. So, you know, it's I don't think it's very it's near as innocent as I don't think it's innocent at all. Anybody think that this is an innocent thing? No, I mean, I I just know you're not going to keep the kids away from it. It's going to happen regardless. But it is concerning who has access to what they are saying and how is that used against them in the future. And on top of that, what is the chat bot going to say back?
What is it going to say back? There's no telling. There's no predicting what it might say back. No. There have been records of them going rogue. Right, and saying some pretty crazy things. I think if I remember right, and I'm going to qualify this by, this may not be the case at all, but I seem to remember a case when I think a chat bot sort of recommended suicide. Suicide, yeah. Yeah, I think that... Now that's a good idea. Yeah, great idea. So there's a great example of what we're talking about.
So what we're not... talking about here today. I mean, we've talked about cheating before, how kids could cheat at school with phones. I mean, these are super phones. And it's not an argument against the use of the technology. It is, however, about authority, privacy, and the moment when a tool begins acting like a relationship, which we are Seeing if you heard that back to school program, you may remember the question was who owns the work of learning. We kind of spread that around and there is some different levels of responsibility.
But when it comes right down to it, it's your grade. Need to do what you need to do to get that grade. AI adds a second question. Who owns what the student tells the machine? And that's an important thing that people are wrestling with right now. Stephanie Tsai of PBS NewsHour sort of thinks about these things in terms of what parents and teachers are facing. Amna, parents and teachers are still trying to get a handle on students' use of social media, and now they're being forced to grapple with AI too.
A recent survey from the Rand Corporation found more than half of U .S. students are using AI for school, an increase of 15 percentage points this year compared to just two years ago. At the same time, 61 % of parents believe AI will harm students' critical thinking compared to just 22 % of school district leaders. All of this as AI juggernaut OpenAI gets even more embedded into the business of American education. Today, it announced a new partnership with school districts across the country. The company says it is giving roughly 400 ,000 K through 12 educators free access to a version of chat GPT through the next academic year.
Let's start by hearing from some parents and teachers grappling with the onset of AI in schools. Hi, my name is LC Carter. My daughter is in the ninth grade and she's 14 years old. I use AI every single day. Of course, I know that they're using AI as well. But she has expressed that she uses it to mostly just kind of help guide her in her writing assignments to make sure that her argument is present, that it's cogent. I'm Crystal Jean and I'm a teacher. Being in this profession for as long as I have, change is always there.
and AI is just another change. It's not going anywhere. Yeah, I really doubt that AI is going anywhere now. Did I hear that right? The parents are more concerned about their children's thought processes than the schools are? I don't know how they would prove that about what's level of concern. I mean, that's what it stated, right? That is what it stated. We're certain. I'm glad you picked that out because I had picked it out a little earlier. Uh, you know, I would have to see how they discern that.
I mean, was that a survey and that, you know, when they gave him a Likert scale on one to 10, that educators indicated a lower level of concern. I think everybody really ought to be concerned about that and educators in particular. I, as a educator, very concerned about. There's all kinds of excuses not to think critically already and if they're not very concerned about it. Doctor, every time you use the word educator, I think euphemism, euphemism, euphemism. Tell me, who are these people? They're not educators.
What are they, Doc? Stop using euphemism. Well, they're supposed to be teachers. They're supposed to be people. Oh, there you go. Supposed. Yeah, they're supposed to be sitting next to the student. They're supposed to be in front of the student discussing a particular subject matter and then helping with misunderstandings, those kinds of things. They're supposed to be teaching people something. You make fun of it. You do comedy. That's funny. PBS reported that more than half of U .S. students use AI for school.
I can't even imagine what kid wouldn't be using at this point unless they just don't have access to the internet. And then at the same time, I would bet that they're finding any way they can to use it to get their work done. That's up 15 points in just two years. And as you heard, parents seem to be far more worried about critical thinking than district leaders, there's another term. Now, let me make a comment there or ask you a question, Doc. I mean, it should deserve and fair those questionable terms, but should not the parents be more concerned than anybody else in the world?
Oh, I do think that they should be the most concerned people. The schools are like an assembly line of left -wing indoctrination. And then I would think the parents, if the parent cared would, then again, now I don't want to hear myself Talking like I think parents care. I mean, I've got a she's proof They care about their child and before I believe it my default is that the kid happens as a result of careless sex and then the parents think oh God what a hassle this is how can we get this kid up in the 18 years 15 60 whatever and bring him out of the house and and keep fooling around maybe he'll have some siblings that'll just happen as an aside to my funny, but No, I don't care.
I couldn't care less getting the hell out of the house schools. Don't care They're indoctrinating. They care more about illegal immigrants. I got up on a diet right there. Sorry, Doc. I interrupted the train of thought. He's a silly, silly man. Silly, silly. I had said it did sound like he was pretty upset about that, didn't it? Oh, no, no, no. I'm fine. He's all right, I guess. He says he's OK. He didn't sound like it. I guess I was surprised because they were talking about critical thinking. And I would think teachers.
would notice it in their classrooms, maybe a lot about the critical thinking, then maybe that's where my thought process was. I'll take issue with the word critical because, you know... And I'll take issue with the word noticed. Okay, then I'm going to take issue with the whole damn thing. Alright! Alright! Let's move on to the Halloween show! So when does this kind of assistance strengthen a student's thinking and when does it replace the thinking? Would you want a teacher to know everything your child is telling AI?
I hope my child wouldn't be telling AI or a teacher very much. I don't want my child talking to a teacher about anything other than the subject matter at hand. That's part of the confusion out there too is... I need to be here for you as, you know, a mentor. I'm your friend. That kind of thing. That's where the lines start to get drawn and when people start to get in trouble. So in schools, the device often arrives before the rules. We watched that with phones and we watched bills sweep across the nation to keep cell phones out of school.
Now we're dealing with this. So... Teachers inherit that new system and parents inherit assurances. No one has yet named the person who's accountable for these things. So after the break, a child sees a conversation. The company behind the chat bot may see a permanent file and a reason to make another sale. You're listening to Doc G and the Discussance. The discussion continues in just a moment. While we take a break, go to docgandthediscussants .com. Meet the Discussants, catch another episode, support the show, visit the shop, or tell your favorite cast member exactly what's on your mind.
Doc G and the Discussants, on sabbatical, back after this. Every successful show has great sponsors. If you'd like to introduce your business to our audience, we'd like you to consider our tremendous sponsorship opportunities. Choose from general admission, mezzanine, front row floor, backstage pass, or executive producer. Every sponsorship includes recognition on the show, founding sponsor status, preferred advertising rates, and additional benefits based on your sponsorship level. You'll find complete details at dgnd .com or docgandthediscussance .com.
Whether you're buying a home, growing a business, planning for retirement, or simply looking for a better place to manage your everyday finances, our local team is here to help. With convenient online and mobile banking, competitive lending options, and people you can actually talk to, Ozark Regional Bank combines modern banking with hometown service. Stop by one of our convenient locations or learn more. Ozark Regional Bank. Local people. Local decisions. Member DICEqual Housing Lender. Insurance has become complicated enough.
Heritage Mutual Group believes coverage should still come with real conversations, straightforward answers, and people you can actually reach when something goes wrong. Whether it's home, auto, business, or life insurance, Heritage Mutual Group works to help protect what matters most without the runaround. Your car should start when you ask it to, it should stop when you need it to, and it should not make a new noise every Tuesday. At Blue Ridge Garage, we handle brakes, batteries, oil changes, tires, and the mysterious sounds you've been ignoring for three months.
Straight answers, fair work, no drama. Blue Ridge Garage. Keep the car. Lose the problem. Don't you wish your life came with a warning app? Just a little heads up before something bad happens. So you can have more control. Uh -oh. Well, life doesn't always give you time to change the outcome, but pre -diabetes does. With early diagnosis and a few healthy changes like managing your weight, getting active, stopping smoking, and eating healthier, you can stop pre -diabetes before it leads to type 2 diabetes.
It's easy to learn your risk. Take the one -minute test today at DoIHavePreDiabetes .org. Warning, the cap is loose on that catam. Don't wait. You have the power to change the outcome. Visit doihabprediabetes .org today. That's doihabprediabetes .org. Brought to you by the Ad Council and its prediabetes awareness partners. And we're back. Remember the program doesn't end when the microphones go off. Visit docgandthediscussants .com. Comment on the show. Suggest a subject. Visit the shop. Support the program.
Or leave something for Doc in the gripe box. Now come back to Doc G and
ho Owns Your Child’s AI Data?
the Discussants on sabbatical. We are talking about your child's relationship with AI and the different sorts of relationships your child has with AI. They have a relationship at school which is supposed to be fairly bounded. It's supposed to be oriented around the particular question at hand in the classroom and it's not supposed to go any farther than that. I really think that that's probably not near as bounded as we think it should be. And then when they're at home, they have a whole other relationship or on their phone with AI.
They can ask all sorts of questions and I can only imagine what I as a young person, young man would have asked AI. I bet I know.
Maybe we'll ask. Tom, the professor, you may have asked, I'm afraid of that. Maybe we'll save that for the Halloween show. We can discuss that. That's a PG show. Well, how much, I wonder, are they actually using AI in the classroom? I mean, the teachers are there to do their subject. for the day. I think teachers better be awful careful about how much they use. Right, exactly. So it's like, why are we relying so much on AI in the classroom anyway? Well, I think that Yeah, there's really good questions about that.
I know in my classroom we just wouldn't do it. We just would not do it because, you know, it would just be one more distraction. It would take away from concentration. Well, if it takes part of the workload away from the educators, then that would be why. Probably. Let me, I don't mean to get in the way of our own program, but I'm going to just tell a very quick story about an educator that I worked with one time. Guy used to teach civics or history, maybe both, I can't remember which. He had been around for quite a while, and what he did one semester was record himself teaching lessons, and then after that, he just ran the tape while he was sitting there.
So, Professor, yeah, and that was... Most of my colleagues reactions to it at the time but not all I think they're like why didn't I think of that a few of them Yeah, I think so. So there you go professor. There's your great example that I personally witnessed Yeah, really before any school approves an AI tool. So here are the seven questions I think they should ask this is the questions I would have asked as a superintendent First what is collected? Who can read it? Who has access to it? How long will this information be retained?
Is it going to be used for training? Are you going to train future bots with our district's information and data? Wouldn't allow that. Can it be sold or reproduced? Can a parent delete it if they'd like to? And who is alerted when there's a data breach, which there most definitely will be. I don't think that they could give me satisfactory answers to any one of those questions. Well, they would try to placate you, by all means. They would, for certain, but I would have been the kind of guy who wouldn't have been placated.
I would have wanted guarantees in writing, and they would have had to show me how to do it. You do that shit, Doctor, you get your ass fired, too. Exactly. Well, yeah, and that would have been an issue because, you know, safety first and thinking about how this could be abused. That isn't the first thought a lot of times, but it would have been with me. And so it would have been awfully hard for them to put this in my district. So and this is not abstract at all. The Federal Trade Commission's 2026 final order against school data vendor illuminate.
followed allegations that a breach exposed personal information belonging to more than 10 million students. 10 million! Illuminate was ordered to limit collection. This is what happened to them as a result. They were ordered to limit collection, delete unnecessary data, and improve security. Okay, so what do they consider unnecessary? That's what I'm talking about. Every word in here needs to be, you know, parsed out, and it's not the way it should be. So this is a Senate Judiciary Committee and Dr. Mitch Prinstein talking about teens and how they share their personal data.
You would be shocked to know how many teens now freely share their health and personal data with chatbots and they would be shocked to know how companies are turning their intimate details into commercial assets. And so it's very commonly done. That was testimony again in front of the Senate Judiciary Committee not very long ago about you know how many teens do this and that they're selling this information. So is an AI chat transcript, an assignment, a student record, a commercial profile, or all three?
What do you think? If the school requires the tool, what meaningful choice does a parent actually have? Homeschooling. We'll get to that in a second, because I think there's some real potential here for homeschool that homeschool parents haven't had before that could be extremely helpful, but... They're still going to use AI. Wait, I'm, yes, but I'm saying that, let's just go back a step. Okay. Do we, anybody here have any confidence that these records can be contained? No. None whatsoever. Let's ask the professor.
I mean, he seems to be entertained by the question. Well, I found it amusing that anything would be. contained. What's going to be contained? I mean, if there's money to be made by somebody who has to leverage your power or position to release it, or whatever, then, well, that's it. Money is at the root again, I think, in some form, way down there. Power is there, too, somewhere, but money... I think you're right, and I think that anyone who believes that this can be contained is... really naive.
Naive. If you really believe this, I think that you've got a large enough mental issue that we need to send you someplace to have your head examined. We'll send you to AI for your mental health review. Right. Well these are just maybe people, these are innocent people that are used to yesteryear's world when things were more gentle, more gracious, people were courteous to one another, that kind of thing. So I don't know if they... exactly need their head exams or anything, but they need to be maybe educated about reality today.
I can't imagine how anyone can't understand that this is a real hazard for data breaches and huge data breaches about very personal things that people have said. There'd be a lot of people that wouldn't even know what you meant when you said data breach. Yeah, I'm sure that's true, but I'm talking about people who are supposed to be entrusted with other people's data and their lives. And if you don't understand by now after you have seen all the data breaches that occur with banks, with hospitals, with schools, with even AI up to this point with Illumina, why would you ever think that you could keep this safe?
Now, I could see where somebody might believe that they could limit the data that it was given. So if there was a breach, it didn't hurt very bad, but there's going to be breaches for certain. And I guess I'm Hey, I'm wearing my new data breaches today. Suede and denim. Love these data breaches. Sounds like a great costume for the Halloween show. Let me get a data breach. Hey, That's an idea. You know, you wear these, okay, well, I might just keep that to myself. Excuse me? Yeah, excuse me. A school contract can impose safeguards.
A child opening a consumer chatbot at home may be operating under a very different policy. I mean, so far we've just talked about when other adults are supposed to be in charge. Now, when they're at home... I'm sorry. I'm sorry. That was funny. Other adults are supposed to be in charge. I'm sorry. I found it humorous. I'm sorry. In charge. OK. Let's reel this back in. This is a serious show regarding artificial intelligence, or as the president terms it, superintelligence. Walter, you have the floor.
and for people's kids, for God's sake. So this is how you guys act. Great. Sorry. You know. This is going to happen. We have to redo this show. Yeah, exactly. This is going to happen. It's going to descend into foolishness and buffoonery and mediocrity. I'm afraid I'm not going to comment. So, you know, if a child's at home and they're messing around with AI, and we've just identified what I think is a pretty big danger. I mean, what are kids going to ask these things? And what answers will they get?
You know, AI kind of will kiss your butt anyway. Yeah, it's going to tell you what you want to hear. It's just brilliant. I mean, they're always telling you how brilliant you are. And, you know, it just was great quality thinking. And even if you are wrong, they will tell you you're right. I mean, it's fun to test it. I have to be. talking to the wrong AI, because it doesn't tell me I'm great. Well, maybe you are. So when we come back... I'll talk to Sarah like I'm AI. Oh, Sarah, you are thinking and talking outside of the box.
Congratulations. Guess what? I'm done with AI. What? Come back, baby. So when we come back, if we come back... You'll never return from this. Right. What happens when the tutor stops sounding like software and starts sounding like one friend who always agrees with you or like the professor which is, you know, troublesome? I mean total concurrence. You're listening to Doc Chi and the discussants.
Need a safe space, love? Time to circle back. Maybe unpack your feelings, protect your mental health and take a little wellness break. Yeah. Wrong show. Around here, if somebody says something you don't like, you're perfectly free to disagree with them. Imagine that. Doc G and the Discussants are taking a commercial break. You might need one. They don't. Some of our best ideas come from the people listening. If you have a question, a comment, a show idea, or maybe someone you'd like us to interview, we'd love to hear from you.
Just visit docgandthediscussants .com, click contact, and choose your favorite discussant. from the drop down menu and send us your message. Your questions, comments or suggestions might even become part of a future episode. Thanks for listening. We appreciate it. Accidents happen. Getting your vehicle repaired shouldn't add to the headache. At Premier Collision and Auto Body, we work with all major insurance companies and handle everything from minor dents and paint repair to major collision damage.
Our technicians use modern repair equipment. computerized paint matching, and manufacturer recommended repair procedures to help get your vehicle back where it belongs, on the road. Free estimates are available Monday through Friday. Premier Collision and Auto Body. Quality repairs, straight answers. Markets change, economies change. Your long -term strategy shouldn't depend on panic and guesswork. Sterling Ridge Financial provides retirement planning, investment guidance, and personalized financial strategies designed around your goals and your future.
Sterling Ridge Financial, steady planning for uncertain times. When your heating or cooling system quits, you don't want a sales pitch, you want it fixed. Call Hartman Heating and Cooling. Our experienced technicians service all major brands and offer repair, replacement, seasonal maintenance, and indoor air quality solutions for homes and businesses. And with 24 -hour emergency service, Hartman is there when you need us most. Call today and ask about our seasonal system check. Hartman Heating and Cooling.
Comfort you can count on. Snakes, zombies, public speaking, the list of fears is endless. But the real danger is in your hand when you're behind the wheel. Distracted driving is what's really scary and even deadly. Eyes forward, don't drive distracted. Brought to you by NHTSA and the Ad Council. Right then, break's over. If you spent it circling back, unpacking your feelings or searching for a safe space, do try to keep up. The rest of us are getting back to the show and while you're there, have a look at docandthediscosence .com.
Episodes, the gripe box and plenty more trouble waiting for you. You're on sabbatical with Doc G and The Discosence. The truth is more interesting than fiction and far more valuable than cliches or talking points.
When a Chatbot Becomes Your Child’s Friend
Back to it. I was just sitting here thinking about how much better this show should be because we basically rehearsed it. And how it's turning out. Yeah, it's not anything like the first one at all. No, not even close. I can't even remember the first one. It was that good. Yeah, maybe you'd like to have a nap, Sarah, while we finish the show. Been there, done that. Yeah, you have been there, done that. Had a little nap while we're doing the show. That's great. Like I said, let's maintain some decorum now.
We were dealing with a very serious subject here. And it is, yeah. AI and people's children and our take on that too. And the educational system and parents and the coordination of the three. Doctor? So, this is not the same product when it's at home. You know, a supervised classroom tool answers a bounded task, or it's supposed to. I don't really believe that. And this is why I don't believe it. We put a lot of computers in school and had computer teachers, business teachers. I would walk into those classes and you would think...
you know, as an administrator to sort of walk through and see what was going on. And you would think a cop had just walked in sometimes to watch these kids click, you know, to make sure that they turned this screen off and think that I wouldn't see it. And what's my teacher doing at the same time? Sitting in her desk, reading a book, and maybe not even a book that had anything to do, you know? Oh, no. Oh, Dr. Eaves. Dr. Eaves, you have a question. Be cool. Countless times, you know, countless times.
So I know that it's not going to stay bounded. A companion bot is built to sustain a relationship, the ones that they use when they're at home. It's available to it any time, midnight, two in the morning, you know, first thing in the morning. They're agreeable. They're flattering. They're patient and able to remember what a child revealed yesterday. and we've already found out that they reveal quite a bit. Common Sense Media's National Representative 2025 survey, so this is a big survey, 72 % of teens had used AI companions and 52 % used them very regularly.
So we're talking a companion, not just using AI as a tool. Yeah, and one third had used them for social interaction, one quarter had shared personal information. So yeah, as a companion. Yeah, I just don't believe one quarter. I believe that they... is high a percentage of 72 % at said teens. I believe 72 % have shared personal information. I don't believe it's just one quarter of those kids. So this is again the Senate Judiciary Committee, Robbie Torney of Common Sense Media talking about the particular numbers.
Polling reveals that three in four teens are already using AI companions. and only 37 % of parents know that their kids are using AI. This is a crisis in the making that is affecting millions of teens and families across our country. They give these chatbots anthropomorphic mannerisms to seem human. They are designed to mirror and validate children's emotions. They program the chatbots with sophisticated memory that capture psychological profiles of our children, including children in your own states.
So we've had this described as a crisis. And I believe that it is, even though it may be amusing to the professor and to Sarah today. Are they considering this a crisis because is it a mental health crisis that they're saying it is? Or what are they considering the crisis, the access that AI has to the kids? Which one is it? Well, I would say that both those things and then much much more Well, because you know, we've got kids that are giving away their very personal information and questions My bed is at this point that there's a lot of AI chatbots that are having much more intimate conversations with children and their parents and I don't think that that's altogether unexpected and they're asking questions that they don't want to ask their friends don't want to ask their parents maybe things that are embarrassing or things that they just want to know about and they don't want anybody else to know that they want to know about you know I mean I I would I'd love to know what they're really asking the chatbots and at this point I don't know whether there's a way to know it without paying the companies to give me the data.
I'm sure there's a lot of people that want to know what the kids are talking about to monetize it. Sure and and so there's there's our incentive there so what does a child learn from a companion that never gets tired? I'll talk to them as long as you're I guess subscription holds up for how many every minute minutes yeah you know we love you so much but then it's like it's like a jail telephone you have 30 seconds by the way your payment is due I love you so much by the way your payment is due sounds like a prostitute doesn't it Okay, never challenges the story and never calls or consults another adult.
I think that that's a really interesting question. When a kid says something totally screwed up to one of these things, enough that it would alarm any one of us, which would be quite a statement, what happens? What happens? I mean, is there an alarm somewhere in the chat GPT land that says, hey, this kid's getting ready to do something pretty crazy to himself or to others? Notify Cash Patel. See, that's where I was headed with it. I'm like, if that's the case, then all these people that plan all these terrorist acts and stuff should never even get as far as they get if they're being But that's monitoring their privacy.
I know. And so that's the double -edged swords we're up against. So how about this? Can simulated empathy become emotional authority before a child understands what the friend... I like the term simulated empathy. I like that. Well, can it become emotional authority before a child understands that the friend is a product? Of course. Yep. Yeah, I think so. And I think that's particularly disturbing. We're talking about people who have no life experience at all. Now, I keep picturing like a 13, 14 year old.
But it doesn't necessarily have to be that it could be much younger. And so let's say that, you know, let's say that Johnny has a favorite imaginary friend is we've sort of couched this entire program. And He just goes down the rabbit hole with this friend. He asks all the questions and of course the answers come back complimentary. They come back kind of like the kid wants to hear them come back. He calls the kid Donnie Darko or whatever he wants to and Donnie comes back and Donnie Darko prose and all of a sudden we, you know, our imaginary friends...
aren't really all so imaginary anymore. The thing you used to make up in your mind, the conversation that you used to make up in your mind is now right there in front of you. And you don't even have to read. You can turn it on computer and it will talk to you too. This is very, very different than anything I think we've encountered before. ideas. How about let's let's see what the professor thinks about this particular, if he's got over his little laughing fit. Yes, I don't find this funny at all, doctor.
I'm serious. Yeah, I think this is my same old thing. This is just simply the way things are going. There's nothing at all we can do about it. We can talk about it and that's what we do. There's not going to be any kind of improvement made. There are not going to be any effective safeguards implemented. It's just going to get progressively, gradually, but progressively worse, more intense. We're in kind of a quiet, widespread chaos. It's just an all -encompassing bovine scat syndrome. The kids are just headed wherever they're headed.
As I said in a previous show, maybe it was even this show that was lost in computer land. There will be a few, rare, far and few between, but self -starting kids that will think, well, I see all this. I see all this foolishness. This is not for me in this life. I'm going to educate myself and improve myself in spite, in spite of this system, in spite of the educators, in spite of AI, I'm going to excel. But those are few and far between. The masses of kids just kind of funneled into this. BS and worse and worse and worse.
The educators don't educate. They slack. They're more worried about their unions and making money and doing as little as they can get by with. The parents don't, for the most part. There are a few exceptions there too, but for the most part they think, oh damn, this kid is such an annoyance. Why didn't we protect our sex, babe? We were having so much fun. Now we got this responsibility. Shit. On it goes, on it goes, back to you, doctor. Yeah, I think that all those things, there's some truth in, a lot of truth in some of it, and some truth in others.
I think that... Well, there's a lot of truth in all of it. I think that it's important that people think very hard about this, because as we've heard people really raise some alarms about... what could happen, you know, maybe the extinction of the human race. The kids are going to bear the brunt of this first, I think, in that they just don't have enough life experience to know when someone is purposely being flattering, especially young kids. And I can see a lot of kids, we know right now that they sort of Get into a world of video games and they become very insulated We're always talking about they're not outside playing anymore.
I mean, so they're already in these really insular worlds now they have a friend that they can tell anything to and get Really good answers back from you know, they're going to trust them a lot. What do you mean by good? What do you what do you mean by good? Let's say they asked them they asked them, you know why an object falls at 9 .82 seconds per second. Why is that? They're going to be able to, a chatbot will be able to quote chapter and verse of Newton's theories on those things. Okay, I'll go along with that if it's that kind of a high tech type question, but what about these emotional subjective personal?
Well, that's what I was sort of getting to. they'll have a lot of credibility with kids because they're getting all this high -quality information from it. So they build a foundation in answering tech questions correctly and that seduces the child using it into asking the subjective questions and believing those answers too even though they're not necessarily true. That's exactly what I'm getting at and so you know it becomes hard for somebody with no life experience to sort of sort those things out.
So I think that We're faced with something pretty sinister here, and those with the right answers, and really the answers are in philosophy, is where the answers are at here, are probably going to be in fairly high demand. So when we come back after the break, a practical rule book, who should control school AI, and what must be in writing before a child logs in? You're listening to Doc G in the Discussance.
If you're wondering what Doc G and the Discussance is all about, here's the short version. Interesting people, interesting ideas, interesting topics. Politics, music, sports, leadership, business, education, technology, history. If it's worth thinking about, it's certainly worth talking about, and it's fair game. We won't chase headlines or repeat talking points. We believe the truth is far more interesting than fiction. More valuable than cliches or Talking points. Learn more at docgandthediscussance .com or thediscussance .com.
Mornings do not need to be complicated. They need coffee. At Maple House Coffee we roast fresh, brew it strong and leave the fancy speeches to somebody else. Hot coffee, cold brew. Fresh pastries, a comfortable chair. That's enough. Maple House Coffee. Good coffee. No meeting required.
Insurance has become complicated enough. Heritage Mutual Group believes coverage should still come with real conversations, straightforward answers, and people you can actually reach when something goes wrong. Whether it's home, auto, business, or life insurance, Heritage Mutual Group works to help protect what matters most without the run -around. Security isn't about reacting. It's about knowing. Deep Blue Home Security. Most people out here think that taking care of one another is important. And most people would step up for a neighbor going through a tough time.
Most people around here help out friends and family when they need it. But the funny thing is most of us won't look for help when we need it. If you're struggling with mental health, you should know that there are resources out there that can help. And it's okay to talk about it if you need to. One place to get started with information is loveyourmindtoday .org. LoveYourMindToday .org offers a range of guides, instructions, and insights for dealing with difficult situations or getting through a tough time.
If you're struggling with mental health, get the help you need, because most people out here really care. Visit LoveYourMindToday .org. That's LoveYourMindToday .org. Brought to you by the Huntsman Mental Health Institute and the Ad Council. If you have need for an emotional support animal, Well, you're in the wrong place. You're on sabbatical with Doc G and the Discussants at the intersection of policy, politics, and culture. Have a question for your favorite discussant? Well, please visit us on the World Wide Web at thediscussants .com.
The Doctor is in.
AI Safeguards: What Parents Should Ask
The conversations your child is having with artificial intelligence both at school now, now schools have embraced this. I mean they're making huge contracts with the AI producers out there and then the relationship they have with AI on their way home on the bus, when they're walking to the bus, when they come home and head to their room that... Some of you parents allow them to lock the door behind them and be in there for hours with AI. Don't come crying to me. Don't come crying to us when bad things happen, when you don't see your kid behind a locked door for hours and hours, especially in this day and age.
Just don't do it because... There's not gonna be a lot of sympathy there. So here's the new standard. Who gets the final say? On September 9th, Microsoft, the American Federation of Teachers and some other teachers' organizations announced a contractually, a contractually enforceable school standard. Right. No training on student or educator data. They're saying, you know, we're not gonna let you train on the data you collect from us. Right. No sale or repurposing. Human oversight. They want human oversight over these things.
They don't understand that every school is using and millions of students are using at the same time and what do they think is going to happen at these data centers? They're going to put somebody on every kid's AI account? They probably do. Not. Yeah, right. School control over retention and deletion of data and plain language transparency for parents. They've been so good at transparency for parents in the last few years. They flat out hide how your child comes to school and how they... co -home and what your child's name is during the school day and they are saying plain language transparency for parents I don't trust them as far as I can throw them and remember these are my former colleagues I felt the same way back then why this matters this is a vendor agreement not national law and not coverage of every product but it proves that trust us can be replaced with terms a district can enforce.
I'm laughing at myself at that. I guess I've been laughing at pretty much everything they've said. Again, the Senate Judiciary Committee, and this is Dr. Mitch Prinstein saying that Congress should make privacy the default for minors. Congress must enact comprehensive data privacy legislation that establishes privacy protection as the default setting for minors and explicitly prohibits their sale of data. I stepped all over his actual... Yes you did. Yeah, I said whatever he was going to say before he said it, which is not...
Well, Congress can't really rule on that. We're going to be off for the holidays for about four and a half weeks. So here would be my test and I'm just going to put it out there. We were talking about maybe trying to provide an answer or two. I would say no student facing AI without these things. Identified instructional purpose. There's strike one. Probably most people couldn't, well they could make one of those up. I've watched them do that. Age limits. I don't know if they're in schools. What is the age limit there?
Human accountability. There is no way that they can guarantee human accountability. Who's going to be accountable for everybody using this tool at once? Parent notice and allowing them to opt out were feasible. They can't opt out now to go to the library for some books that are there. Data minimization. That means, you know, not letting them have all the data that they would like to have. Retention and deletion schedules. How long do we keep the data? When do we delete it? How do we ensure that it's deleted?
A schedule of those things. independent safety testing. That's just one I sprinkled in there. I have no idea how you're going to independently test this thing. And crisis sounds important. Yeah, it does. And this is how legislation gets written is sprinkle some stuff in here that sounds good. Yeah, and then everybody will think it's safe. Then crisis protocol, you know, so what happens in a crisis? Did you notice my use of crisis? protocol again sounding good and then annual public review you know so every year the public can review this like they're going to have access like they're going to have access to it so they're even going to do it both things both things are right so Tom Cruise Mission Impossible movie or something?
I think it was, was it The Ghost Protocol? Is that what it was? Oh, okay, yeah, yeah, yeah, you're right. Well, it's probably about as useful in that movie as is in Doc G's test here for a while, AI should be in schools. So let's just go to the discussants on this. Where would each of you, and I guess we'll start with Sarah, draw the line? Is it a useful tutor, a private, confident, therapeutic language? Hey, there's something that's, you know, got every educator's attention out there. Persistent memory or under 16 access?
What do you think makes a difference here? What do I think makes a difference? Yeah, where would you draw the line? I guess I asked two different questions, so let me go back to the first one. Where would you draw the line? Is AI a useful tutor, a private confidant, therapeutic language, persistent memory, and under 16 access. Or you can draw a line wherever you want to. I was just giving a few ideas. I don't know about the lines. I think the lines are too blurred. I don't think the lines are going to even exist or even currently exist.
Kids are going to use it regardless. I don't think parents are going to be able to stop them. I'm not sure. Again, I'm curious how much it actually is used in the classroom because I don't have an idea on that. Well, it's used in the classroom whether the teachers allowed it or not right now. I'm telling you. And then there's a lot of teachers that don't have the control of their classroom to know what's going on in there. Right. Watched it personally for years and years. Well, yeah. I mean, the kids are going to be using it whether the teacher is aware or not.
That's right. Right. Yes. But I mean, I... You're not going to stop it kids are going to do it. They're going to find a way around it Even if you say no just like we did growing up just went through that with cell phones We just went through it and it came to a place where they had to make Legislation to try to get a hold of it, which won't get a hold of it Those phones are still in the classrooms. Don't let them kid you about that I wanted to say just while while you're here because you said something earlier about homeschooling I think this is a big tool for homeschooling and that Parents who don't have expertise in particular, subject matter now, can have a lot easier time teaching that along with textbooks.
Along with AI. Because it's like having a tutor for whatever subject right by your side and used. Effectively, it would let a lot more people get into the home schooling business. So the parents really aren't teaching, they're relaying. Well, let's just say we're trying to teach something about advanced physics. Most people can't. They don't know page one. But if they're teaching their students at home and there's... plenty of good reasons for homeschooling. They might have a lot better shot now, or at least of watching what they're doing with other teachers.
So I think it could be a big, big tool for education used correctly, and especially for homeschool parents who haven't had this power before. Let's go to the professor. Let's see. What do you think? I mean, I guess you pretty much. I'm going to need a specific question. This whole thing has become far too nebulous for me to grasp. It was basically, where would you draw a line? Is it the useful tutor part? Is it the private confidant? Is it the therapeutic language that kids are getting from AI now?
A persistent memory of who you are? Are you seen and heard? I think I'm going to subscribe to Sarah's notion of... Drawing a line it seems like drawing a line is some kind of idealistic BS. That's not going to exist Yeah, I think it's going to be very hard to keep this under control if it's able to be kept under control There's plenty of thinkers out there that are saying it cannot be I don't think it can be and so if that's Where we're at on it, then we can expect some real trouble not just from schools and kids Now we're talking about adults who intend to use this for nefarious purposes or whatever else.
Right. Yeah. I know I use it a lot. I know you use it a lot and you know it's it's I'll be wearing my glasses and I'll be driving down the road and I'll just ask a question you know that came to my mind as I'm driving down the road and I'll get my answer you know and I find that coming into my life on a daily basis when I'm not wearing my glasses and I think I am or whatever and so I think for kids it's probably even more you know just like they've grown up with phone and internet and Facebook and they don't know anything other it's it's a I think Sarah should explain the glasses just a tad more for those who are uninitiated.
I have some smart glasses. I have some meta glasses. And so I can just ask a question and it will answer the question. I don't always agree with what it says and then we'll have a little argument and there I am acting like it's an actual person arguing back and forth. So imagine if you're a kid. doing that. Yeah, you should know better. Right. Yeah. But the kid doesn't. Right. And I do know better, but I do argue with it. No, no. And I mean, she's getting some entertainment out of it. And it is entertaining.
And it would be very entertaining. And especially for kids who have problems, they don't have a lot of friends. You know, the era, the era of the kid who never talks to anyone is over and they can have that friend with them all the time, all night long. What does that do? I mean, it's really an interesting set of circumstances. It reminds me of all these shows that we watch, the reality shows that aren't actually reality, like the 90 Days and the Catfishes and the whatever, where people have carried on, quote, relationships with people that they don't know, haven't met.
But I've always felt like there's just something missing in those people that are doing this. Is that the same way with these kids using AI with relationships? We do not know yet. Is there something missing? Again, it's very early on. They don't have... We're all going to learn together. Friends? Or what? I'm afraid that we might learn some pretty hard lessons along the way because it's... I don't know. It's scary. It's very new. You've been listening to Dr. G here in the Discussion Zone. As we...
Like and subscribe. As we... As we solve the problem of your kid talking to AI, one thing I will say before we clear out of here is, well, first, the Halloween show. Make sure you're here because that's going to be the definitive Halloween show. Secondly, you need to watch your kids. You need to know what they're doing and when they're doing it, especially in this brave new world. And there's far too much of that. There's just far too much of it, and this is getting to be a pretty dangerous world.
Thanks for listening. We'll see you on Friday, and we'll talk about Halloween. And so ends another hour. The arguments have been made. The questions have been asked. And what you believe from here is entirely up to you. No approved conclusion. No talking points to take home. Just one final thought. The truth is more interesting than fiction and far more valuable than cliches or talking points. For the professor, Sarah, and everyone behind the microphones, this is Doc G and the Discussants on sabbatical.
Until next time.
Podbean