The Hardest Working Thanksgiving Show in Show Business Show! Presidents, Family Feuds & the Great American Feast
This Episode
This Thanksgiving, Doc G & The Discussants are putting on a show! We begin with the 1621 harvest gathering and the remarkable distance between history and the story most Americans grew up hearing. Then meet Sarah Josepha Hale, the relentless advocate who helped turn Thanksgiving into a national observance. And finally: the astonishing 1939 “Franksgiving” controversy, when President Franklin Roosevelt moved the holiday and left the country arguing over the calendar. Along the way, Doc G and Sarah tackle turkey and dressing, family traditions, unforgettable holiday mishaps, premature Christmas decorations, and a special Thanksgiving edition of Doc’s Gripe Box. Three historical chapters, plenty of laughs, and a sincere holiday sendoff—just in time for our Thanksgiving-week break. Visit docgandthediscussants.com, share the show with your best friends, and join us again when new episodes resume November 30.
The Thanksgiving Story You Never Heard
from Doc G, Sarah, the Professor, and everyone at Doc G and the Discussants on sabbatical happy holidays. Whatever this season brings you, family, old friends, a little peace, or one more lively argument around the table, we hope you find something worth celebrating while you're celebrating. Shop the Doc G store at dotganthediscosence .com and send us your holiday gripes and letters to Santa at Doc G Show Studio at gmail .com. We may read some of them on the show. Thank you for spending part of your year with us.
Happy holidays from Doc G and the Discussants. Indeed. Happy holidays from Doc G and the Discussants. Oh my, isn't that physical music wonderful? It was wonderful. It made you feel all warm inside, didn't it? And it was the hardest working Thanksgiving show and show business show. We promised it, and here it is. Complete with a little holiday music that has already warmed the professor's soul. I knew it would. I just knew it would. So we're putting Thanksgiving to work as we sort of, I don't know, suggested the feast that became a legend.
A woman who made it a national cause and the president who managed to start a fight over the calendar. Plus the food, the relatives, and we have a special edition of gripe box, the hardest working Thanksgiving show and show business show edition of the gripe box. And, uh, uh, of course, this is the hardest working podcast and show business. So it's completely appropriate that we'd have the hardest working Thanksgiving show. Right? Yeah. She's looking, you should see the way. that's her is looking at me like have you lost your mind i think she's he's he's he's just staring at me like what what is wrong with you i don't know what i think the name of the show is longer than the show i think the name of the show is long it well maybe you know if you've visited i don't want to i don't want to interrupt the professor because I'm just in the spirit of the season.
I can't seem to shake it. Normally, he's really not in the spirit of the season. He's like the last guy you want to be around if you want some holiday cheer. You don't want to be within a block of the professor if it's about the holidays. I'd like to hear some Burrow Lives. Yeah, Burrow Lives and the Holidays is exactly what everybody needs to really put them in the mood or the professor singing. Christmas carols, which is a first for me. I think I've known the professor since somewhere around, I don't know, 1986 or so, and it's the first Christmas carol I've ever heard him say.
So, I mean, we've got a first here. It's the first time for everything. For certain, and it really is a first. You know, if you visited Plymouth in autumn 1621, I'm old, but not that old. If we got into the time machine. Okay. Are we going to burn a witch? You would recognize, would you recognize the Thanksgiving dinner? Well, probably not. The gathering was a harvest celebration and the familiar holiday narrative was assembled much, much later than that. That's my contention, doctor. That's what it pertains to.
You hit it exactly. And I get tired of people interpreting Thanksgiving. as some kind of modern symbolism regarding being thankful for what they have in their lives, and that it's what you said it is, it isn't what I was comparing it to. Back to you, Doctor. Oh, thanks. There's the old blah humbug that I'm more familiar with. There it is. There it is right there. I can't say my Christmas phrase on air. Why why can't you say your Christmas? You don't want me to first is Thanksgiving, okay?
Here's a little clip from First I've got to set this up by where we got it from it came from PBS So I guess we can all put the PBS forces on So much fun Fun. Is it going to lean left? Yes, it may lean left. But, you know, have fun. It's so much fun. We should all just be so thankful. We should be thankful. Fun. It's fun. The first Thanksgiving from the folks at PBS. Now, I want to turn to the first harvest meal. We've talked about the year 1621 when this occurred, when the Plymouth Plymouth colonists and the Wampanoag people shared an autumn harvest feast that I think is acknowledged today as one of the first thanksgivings in the colonies.
I know there are a lot of uncertainties around it, but what do we know about what actually happened? Well, we are lucky that we do have a source. Edward Winslow wrote a letter to a friend back in England describing the event. And so he does give us a lot of facts. We know that it lasted three days. We know that they had wild fowl, that they went out hunting for fowl. We know that there was feasting and sporting. And we know that there were about 50 Englishmen there and more than 90 Wampanoag. So the Wampanoag were there?
Yes. But the thing is also, if it's some type of gathering, you'd probably bring women and children. Massasoit, who comes from Poconoquit, believed that he stopped at every village coming down from Rhode Island down to here and gathering penises. The relationship was still new between these two cultures at that time, because the treaty was signed in spring. So anything could really happen at any point. But as the document is written, we know that Massasoit sent out five warriors to shoot five deer.
And Massasoit was the leader? Of the Poconoque. Of the Poconoque, yes. And he sent those men out, and in native ways, when you're gifting somebody, we know that everything's in a good way. And so, as a gift at the feast, you would bring food for the settlers? Right. Okay. Looks much like what we do today, I guess, right? We all bring food over for our big Thanksgiving meal. Speaking of, you mentioned feasting. Can you tell us a little bit, actually Constance, can you maybe tell us a little bit about the food that was eaten at the first harvest meal?
Yeah, truly. I did help my mother to prepare the food and I did help her to prepare the fish that we did have. We've roasted the duck father shot that day. He was a foaling and he shot down a duck. We'd roasted that together. Yeah, we did have some of the native corn of this country. We had some of that. And the pumpkin that is native. That's a standing dish here. We eat that all the time this time of year. Those were some of the things. Yeah, very good things. And Habamak, what did the Wampanoag contribute to the feast?
The warriors brought A takwag, a deer? Venison. Yes. Sporting, you mentioned. So I'd love to know what events took place, what sporting events took place. There's always stool ball and that sort of thing, and the pitching of the bar where the men take a great beam and see how far they can cast it and which man can cast it the farthest. A good test of strength for the men in the town, they feel that. And of course, exercising their arms. That is always entertaining for us to see the men shooting off their guns and practicing their military skills because it is important for us to know we are safe.
But also very, it's a good entertainment to watch them do that. And they did that that day also. And today men hoist a big leather pigskin and they throw it up in the air at holiday time. We call it football. You throw it with your hand. Yes, we throw it with our hands. That's right. What the hell was that? I told you, I warned you. It's PBS. Gee, what is this? Doctor, did she say pissing at the fire? Did I misunderstand that? I don't know. I don't know. Of course, they were all sitting around this little conversation pit in character.
Oh my god, seriously? That's why you got what you got. But how much fun? How much fun was that? Oh my goodness, that looks like fun. And did you notice how they tied the old traditions into the new ones, into the new ones of football, where they cast the pole and they cast the pigskin. I would expect nothing less. I did warn you, I warned everybody. where the cut came from, and I knew that it would, of course, be fun for us after it was over. I don't even know what to say about that. I really don't know what to say.
Good fun. It was good fun. I think we can call it good fun. Such fun. I kept wanting Adam Sandler to start singing the Thanksgiving song somewhere along the line. So what Thanksgiving fact, besides the ones that were just laid on us by PBS, did you learn in school? What did you learn about Thanksgiving in school? What did you learn? I don't remember learning anything about it, actually. Nothing. Well, let's go. I think I concur. Nothing. Like, no hand turkeys? Oh, yeah. That's the only thing I remember is the arts and crafts associated with it.
I don't remember anything else specifically. Well, you'd put your hand down and trace it. Now, didn't somebody show up here on this continent and there were already people living here and then these people showed up and they more or less muscled the natives into like a... some little designated area and they more or less procreated and took over the continent. Isn't that kind of what went down? Well, I think that that's how the textbooks write it now. It used to be when I was growing up, it was it was all in the in good fun.
It was all in good fun. Wasn't there a Plymouth Rock? Oh, you know, one of those little cartoons about Plymouth Rock? Sure. Schoolhouse Rock. That's it. Yeah. Back when they would do that without making sure that the settlers were evil.
There's plenty of evilness going on. If we travel to England, say for example, and we thought, oh, all right, we've discovered an island here, or a continent, let's go ashore, and oh my goodness, there are already people living here. Well, perhaps we can get together and have a feast and then proceed to take over their land. That's happened. That's happened in the world forever. I didn't think we'd get any postmodern theory here on the Thanksgiving show. That's happened across the world forever.
It appears that that's what we had. It's not anything new. Yeah, Vikings. Yeah, exactly. Polynesian people just spreading out throughout. I mean, it's the way of the world, sorry. It's the way of the world, isn't it? has been and always will be that way. And will continue to be. And will continue to be. And will continue to be. And will continue to be. And will continue to be. And will continue to be. And will continue to be. And will continue to be. Boy, we're off to a good start here in the Doc G and the Discussants artist working Thanksgiving show.
Happy Thanksgiving to everyone. Happy Thanksgiving from Doc G and the Discussants. From Doc G, Sarah, the Professor, and everyone at Doc G and the Discussants on sabbatical, Happy Holidays. Whatever this season brings you, family, old friends, a little peace. or one more lively argument around the table, we hope you find something worth celebrating. Thank you for spending part of your year with us. We'll keep asking questions, telling stories, and finding the truth behind the talking points. Happy holidays from Doc G and the Discussants.
The people around this table have a lot in common. They're all accomplished and interesting. They've spent their lives behind microphones, built businesses, taught students, designed and built remarkable machines. Made music -led organizations solve problems and entertain audiences for years. They're talented, experienced, and every one of them are people you want to know. That's what makes them Discussance. Meet the people behind the microphones at docgandthediscussance .com. When your heating or cooling system quits, you don't want a sales pitch.
You want it fixed. Call Hartman Heating and Cooling. Our experienced technicians service all major brands and offer repair, replacement, seasonal maintenance, and indoor air quality solutions for homes and businesses. And with 24 -hour emergency service, Hartman is there when you need us most. Call today and ask about our seasonal system check. Hartman Heating and Cooling. Comfort you can count on. We work with all major insurance companies and handle everything from minor dents and paint repair to major collision damage.
Our technicians use modern repair equipment, computerized paint matching, and manufacturer -recommended repair procedures to help get your vehicle back where it belongs, on the road. Free estimates are available Monday through Friday. Premier Collision and Auto Body. Quality repairs, straight answers. Weekend project, emergency repair, full renovation. Mill Creek Hardware has the tools, supplies, and practical advice to help get the job done and done correctly. From plumbing and electrical to outdoor equipment and seasonal supplies, Mill Creek Hardware believes customer service still matters.
Mill Creek Hardware. Built for people who still like doing things themselves. Real talent is defined by what people can do, not where they learn to do it. So by stopping at the education section of a resume, you might throw away the perfect hire. You might miss someone who has valuable skills to offer, to help your business thrive right now and in the future. Because the truth is this. Skills First Hiring helps you see talent others miss, like more than 70 million stars, skilled through alternative routes.
When you let their story unfold, you gain a competitive advantage. Because hiring managers who start with skills are 60 % more likely to find a successful hire. See the real person. Complete. See what others miss. Hire skills first. Competitive advantage. At tearthepaperceiling .org. Brought to you by Opportunity at Work and the Ad Council. Alright, enough hanging about. We've had the adverts, now let's get back to the argument. Sharp questions, straight answers, and no nonsense dressed up as wisdom.
The truth is more interesting than fiction and far more valuable than cliches or talking points. Doc G and the Discosence on sabbatical, the hardest
he Woman Who Made Thanksgiving Happen
working podcast in show business. Well, the questions today are considerably less sharp than usual from the hardest working Thanksgiving show and show business show. That's all we're doing today. Screwing around a little bit for Thanksgiving. We're gonna be gone next week We'll be back Monday November the 30th, but we're all gonna take the week off because It's just fun now the professor he may not Uh, he's not really into eating anything with a face or a mother. So, uh, correct sir. Right. And so, you know, not, not as big a deal to him, but he was singing.
He used to go at a radio station long ago and far away at some little radio station where I worked. The holidays came around. I was expecting a generous cash bonus instead. What? You were expecting. I know. It wasn't that naive of me and idealistic. I was, I was young and foolish, but. they gave me they gave us all a dead bird oh boy luckily i found someone that wondered it yeah i remember the canned ham the canned ham a couple of times didn't they play at woodstock yeah they were the openers for canned heat i think oh yeah Canned ham was the opening for canned heat?
It's all just stupidness, Sarah. It's all just dumb. Oh, okay. I'm like, what the heck is that? You know, it took more than... What the hell are you talking about? Yeah, that's pretty much what I was thinking. What are you talking about, Willis? It took more than two centuries and one extraordinarily persistent woman to even put Thanksgiving on the national calendar. So, if you're thinking that it's always been this way, uh -uh. close Sarah Josepha Hale she was an editor and a writer and an advocate who pressed national leaders for a common Thanksgiving observance over many many years so Thanksgiving really wasn't celebrated at the same time every year by everyone in the United States it was it was why different different dates, different ways of celebrating.
It wasn't uniform at all. Among the states were all kinds of different celebrations. Stop right there. Now, tell me, clarify at this point, please. What are they? What were they celebrating exactly? What were they celebrating? They were all sort of celebrating harvest. and some celebrating Thanksgiving sort of like we might conceive of it, but there were all sorts of different celebrations, but everybody was kind of having a fall harvest celebration, so it was kind of a national thing, but it wasn't all on the same day.
It only happened as a national holiday after President Lincoln's proclamation, and that sort of solidified it a bit. but it still wasn't celebrated on the same day. Let's go to the story of Miss Hale. Did you know one woman spent years trying to get America to celebrate Thanksgiving on the same day? Her name was Sarah Josepha Hale. For decades, states celebrated Thanksgiving at different times, or not at all. Hale wrote to governors and presidents, urging a National holiday that could bring Americans together.
Finally, in 1863, President Abraham Lincoln issued a Thanksgiving proclamation during the Civil War. She didn't invent Thanksgiving, but her persistence helped turn a scattered tradition into a national observance. So we haven't really had Thanksgiving, as we might know it, until the Civil War, which for us... now has been quite a while. But before that, it was just kind of a hosspodge of people kind of having a feeling about Thanksgiving and fall harvest, but nothing on the books until President Lincoln put it on the books.
So what Thanksgiving fact again did you learn in school? I mean, I really learned that... I would have thought before I did research into Thanksgiving that it had kind of been around in a formal way for much longer than the Civil War because it's presented in school as such a hardened fact. Fact, you know, it's presented as a hardened fact where the native peoples and the pilgrims got together to celebrate the harvest and that ever after that there has been Thanksgiving. You know, the buckled hats, everybody getting together inside the fort to celebrate Thanksgiving, and the Native Americans helping the settlers get through their first winters.
That was really presented as a known fact, and probably a lot of that is sort of presented as a known fact. I guess I thought it had probably always been around. Is it surprising to anyone else that maybe it's not been? It kind of surprised me. Yeah, I didn't know that I hadn't always been around. Yeah. Well, I hadn't. Why is that so funny? Well, it's not really what you were saying exactly per se, but it was kind of a... Don't know for me. It kind of nutshell paradise the entire thing But back to you doctor Gonna leave me with it.
Okay. Well, thanks Straighten straighten it all out. Please get it back on track The holiday table, you know everybody gets around the holiday table and and They host and they cook now. It's kind of turkey. Uncle Raymond gets drunk and starts making passes at his niece and they have to call the police in because a fight erupts between uncle Raymond and his brother drunk and his brother and then and then you have you know the the proverbial the perennials what I should say a fight between turkey and ham the stuffing versus dressing sweet potatoes which I don't like at all cranberry sauce which I don't like it all I can honestly say there is really nothing at the standard Thanksgiving feast, per se, that I like.
It's never been my favorite food. No. I think that's an intelligent observation. Most, you know, pie rankings. What about pie? I hate pumpkin pie. I absolutely detest pumpkin pie. What pie do you eat during Thanksgiving? What would you expect to have that would be better? Cheesecake. Cheesecake. Yes. Well, I think that that's usually on the menu for people, isn't it? I don't know. Usually I can remember growing up it was always stupid crap like pumpkin pie, pecan pie, crap like that. My mom would either make chocolate or lemon for me though.
Just for you, because you're so special. And your hiding is shiny. Yes, it is. Thank you very much. I think they were more concerned about how small I was. Sarah was tiny when she was growing up. Notice he said when. Yeah, she was just like a little bitty person. And so her mom was always worried about her and trying to get some more weight on her because she was so little. So can you remember your first Thanksgiving away from home when you were kind of by yourself and how weird that was? I kind of remember the first time I was away from family on Thanksgiving.
It was one of my first years in college. I think it might have been maybe my junior year of undergrad school and I found myself by myself in the town I was going to school in because I had to I was working in college radio at the time and somebody had to run the radio station that day and you know I think I either drew a short straw or I can't remember how the lottery exactly worked but I had to be on the air and I kind of had to do like a double shift because there's another person was supposed to sort of help out wasn't going to be able to so i was on the air all day long and everybody else is having you know thanksgiving in there uh...
you know the families gathered and for the first time i'm not with anybody uh... it with the family setting at all i'm by myself building your future doctor brilliant radio career yeah Or at least I I didn't have any inkling of that at all, but It was weird. It was where did you go for dinner? I there was no dinner It was I mean, maybe it was McDonald's or something like that was open. Yeah, I can't remember exactly how it went but I remember being on the phone with my family a little later on thinking is this weird or what it was kind of like that sunday morning sidewalk uh...
saw him later that night the doctor left the studio went down to a local club and left there with a stripper and disappeared into the night i probably would have gone to a bar if any would have been available at that time because i was actually kind of depressed it was really weird it just you know just because You know how quiet it is on like Christmas Day and Thanksgiving Day around town. Not very much open. Everybody's kind of at home. Things are quiet. It was even more quiet for me because it was the first time I was sorted by myself on that day.
So it was weird. Do you have any memories like that? Well, I don't. Maybe Sarah does. The main one that stands out to me as much was we were going to my grandma's Houston and she was she was sick and I can remember taking her some of the Thanksgiving crafts I had made at school and you know that's that's the only one that really stands out for me I'm sure that we always had to work somewhere they're serving Thanksgiving dinners so it wasn't like a home thing And so what crafts do you take? Do you remember it that well?
What did you bring? Oh, you know, you had the turkey that was, yeah, probably the hand turkey that you were talking about and just some pictures that had been colored at school and stuff like that. Yeah. But yeah, I was probably in second or third grade. So. Well, you know one president moved Thanksgiving for the shopping season actually. Oh, yeah, and America responded with two Thanksgivings and The radio comedians noticed when we come back. We'll play part one of a classic Jack Benny Halloween show Halloween God, I'm still thinking of the definitive Halloween show the Jack yeah Thanksgiving show that mentions two, three different dates of Thanksgiving, not from, I believe, 1939.
When we come back, you're listening to Doc G and the discussions on Thanksgiving. Before we continue, perhaps you'd like to circle back, unpack the conversation, sit with it, process it, and make sure everybody feels heard. Or you could simply decide whether it makes any sense. Bit radical, I know. This is Doc G and The Discussance. The truth is more interesting than fiction. And far more valuable than cliches or talking points. We'll be back. It's worth arguing about this week. Ask Doc G. Then ask The Discussance and stand back.
Three times a week, they take the stories everybody's talking about and find the part everybody missed. Serious questions. Different perspectives. A show that knows how to move. Doc G and The Discussance on sabbatical. New episodes Monday, Wednesday and Friday. Subscribe wherever you listen. The hardest -working podcast in show business. Planning for retirement? Or simply looking for a better place to manage your everyday finances? Our local team is here to help. With convenient online and mobile banking, competitive lending options, and people you can actually talk to, Ozark Regional Bank combines modern banking with hometown service.
Stop by one of our convenient locations or learn more today. Ozark Regional Bank. Local people. Local decisions. Member FDIC Equal Housing Lender.
From premium mattresses and living room furniture to dining sets and home accents, Oak & Iron focuses on comfort, durability, and timeless design without the pressure and confusion of the big box stores. Visit Oak & Iron Home Center and see the difference for yourself. Insurance has become complicated enough. Heritage Mutual Group believes coverage should still come with real conversations, straightforward answers, and people you can actually reach when something goes wrong. Whether it's home, auto, business, or life insurance, Heritage Mutual Group works to help protect what matters most without the runaround.
Doc G, Sarah, the professor, and everyone at Doc G and the discussants on sabbatical, Happy holidays. Whatever this season brings you, family, old friends, a little peace, or one more lively argument around the table, we hope you find something worth celebrating while you're celebrating. Shop the .g store at .ganthediscosence .com and send us your holiday gripes and letters to santa at .gshowstudio at gmail .com. We may read some of them on the show. Thank you for spending part of your year with us.
Happy holidays from Doc G and the discussants.
The President Who Moved Thanksgiving
We are planning on reading some letters to Santa on the show for the fantastic Christmas show that will be held here on this particular show in just a few weeks. If you've got some funny stuff for Santa, a good place to send it to would be to the show. If you want to stuff it in the gripe box, that's fine. And speaking of the gripe box, in the next segment, we will open up the gripe box for a few Thanksgiving gripes. That's coming up, so hang around. You know, again, it's the hardest working Thanksgiving show and show business show.
And in 1939, Thanksgiving tradition fell. on the last Thursday in November. Roosevelt, President Roosevelt, announced an earlier observance hoping to lengthen the pre -Christmas retail season. States did not follow the same date and it took quite a little bit longer for things to solidify. I thought that might open up a discussion for us. The lengthened shopping season was what the president was hoping for. That would have been the teeth of depression, so he's probably hoping to move some money around.
Is there any shopping season anymore? I mean, after thanks, or after, geez, I confused them again. After Halloween was over, even before, we started seeing. Christmas. Oh yeah, for sure. And what that's been going on now several years where there's really no transition period where you go, right, well we don't go from Halloween to Christmas. Christmas is basically kind of going on simultaneously with the last couple of weeks of Halloween in the stores, isn't that right? Which is, to me, sort of depressing because, you know, the holiday season, you know, there's There used to be different flavors starting with Halloween.
Now, I don't think most people would have categorized Halloween as, you know, a holiday, part of the holiday season. It was sort of the front door to it, wasn't it? Yeah, it didn't used to have the same effect that it does now. Now it's really large. Yeah, I think a lot of people would call Halloween maybe part of the holiday season now, including, I think, me now, I would. But then, no, I mean, the most you did for Halloween was put some stupid pumpkin in your window, like one of those You know, pictures of a pumpkin with a witch on top of it, maybe a black cat in the window.
Yeah, you stuck it on with a piece of tape. Your mom did. And that was the Halloween decoration. They decorated you to go outside for trick or treat. And that was it. You know, there's no other decoration. You know, there is decorating going on at Doc G's house for Halloween. In fact, we just got done taking that stuff back to storage. It took the better part of the day just to load it in a trailer. after it was already packed up, which took another day. But really no Thanksgiving. Part of the reason why this Thanksgiving show has been undertaken is because I don't think it's appreciated enough.
Well, you know, it used to be the Black Friday shopping was the main reason for Thanksgiving. You spent Thanksgiving Day... planning your shopping and what stores you were going to and so forth and so on. You don't have to do that anymore. First off, Black Friday starts, what, in October? November, for sure. Yeah, I don't know if there's any real Black Friday. Not very long ago, it used to really cause fist fights. Oh yeah, I've seen them. I've seen them. They would line up outside Walmart or whatever store.
Really early in the morning what? For the morning the lines would start maybe even earlier if there was some hot toy on the market people would get into line and You know they would all go in and grab You know off these pallets and of course that would start fist fights now I haven't heard of that in a while because I think what what are people are basically doing their shopping online Are they not well it starts early now? So like you have early access, certain people you can get early access to the stores that you're wanting to go to so forth.
Like if you're a Walmart plus member, you get early access. Amazon's kind of the same way. If you're a prime person, you get early access to things. So yeah, you can do the same Black Friday shopping online without having to go into the store. So. Yeah. So I don't think it's. Oh, it's still a thing. It's still a thing kind of, but it was not like it was. And I'm not talking, when I say was, not that long ago. You know what, maybe five, six, maybe 10 years at most. But it was still a still a thing.
So as I said, the country used to celebrate on different days. Think about what that would be like now. I mean, it doesn't even seem plausible if you coordinated. how schools let out for the holiday or, you know, TV schedules. Let's say, you know, the holiday football schedules, those sorts of things. I mean, I can't even see how it was once done that way, but it certainly was. I wanted to give you a taste of what it used to be like back around 1939. This is Jack Benny with his Thanksgiving special.
This one's Carey Berry Bean, a swing version of an old favorite played by Phil Harrison as orchestra. And now, fellas... Hey, what's the matter? Aren't you gonna complain about the number we just played? No, Phil, I thought it was pretty good. I liked it, didn't you, Mary? Yeah, it was swell. Did you like it, Don? I thought it was okay. How'd you like it, Jack? Oh, it was great. How'd you like Phil's number, Mary? Well, I thought it was a little loud in spots, didn't you, Don? Yes, it seemed a little off here and there.
What did you think of it, Jack? I thought it was lousy.
And now, fellas... Hey, what is this, a rib? Yes, Phil, we were just kidding. I thought your number sounded exceptionally good. Didn't you, Mary? Seal me out. I'm tired. Now, fellas, as I started to say a little while ago, and before I forget it, Thursday being Thanksgiving, I want all of you to come over to my house for a real old -fashioned turkey dinner. How about it? Oh, that's great, Jack. We'll be there with you. Dennis, Dennis, this invitation goes for you also. His mother, too? Yes, Mrs. Day, my party wouldn't be complete without you You don't sound very sincere about it Well, what do you want me to do, send you a mash note?
Glad to have you, the more the merrier Good heavens Say, Jack Is this party gonna be like the one you gave last Thanksgiving? What do you mean? I mean, is the turkey gonna be like a lamb? Don't worry about that, Mary This is gonna be a real dinner I've got the biggest, fattest, juiciest turkey you ever saw Where'd you run over it? I didn't run over it's a live turkey I got in my garage right now it's roosting on my Maxwell that's all that car needs Are you waiting to see that bird? I bet it weighs 65 pounds.
65 pounds? Why, Jack, you must be mistaken about that. Oh, no, I'm not, Don. I had it on the scales. It's an enormous thing. 65 pounds? Are you kidding? I'm not kidding. Wait till next Thursday and you'll see for yourself. It's gonna be a swell party. How many people are you expecting, Jack? Well, there'll be our gang, and then I invited Clark Gable and Carol Lombard, Bob Taylor and Barbara Stanwyck, Tyrone Power and Annabella. Oh, Jack, you always ask them to every party you give and they never show up.
Well? Why don't you stop inviting them? I can't stop now. They'll think I'm mad at them. You know how it is. How can they be mad at you when they don't even know? I don't even know them! Listen, Phil, I know every one of those stars personally. Sure, Jack sells them their Christmas cards. Mary, will you stop harping on that? The only reason you ever got cards for me is because I happen to have some left over. Every year. Oh, quiet. Don't forget, fellas, Thursday night at my house. Boy, we're gonna have a big turkey and cranberry sauce and mashed potatoes.
And Don, guess what kind of jello we're gonna have for dessert. Strawberry? No. Raspberry? No. Cherry? No. Orange? No. Lemon? No. Give up? Yes. Lie. You see, Don, you almost had it. There's a kindergarten commercial if I ever heard one. Never mind, that's what we're gonna have. Now look kids, if I don't see you again before Thanksgiving, be sure to be at my house by seven o 'clock sharp. And don't eat a big lunch, so you'll really enjoy the turkey. I'll take it. Hello? Hello Mr. Benny, this is Rochester.
Alright, what do you want? Well boss, I just heard you talking about a big Thanksgiving party Thursday night. That's my night off! I'm sorry Rochester, but you'll have to work. You can take a day off some other time. I can get my twin brother to take my place. I don't want your twin brother. Well, he looks just like me. I don't care if he does. I want you to be at my house on Thursday night. How about me in spirit and my brother in person? Rochester, don't try any tricks. I can tell the difference between you and your twin brother.
That's more than this gal can. Never mind, now look Rochester, I want you to get that turkey up to 70 pounds by Thanksgiving, so go out in the garage and feed it. I'm working on a Christmas card! They can wait! You know, the President could move the date but he could not solve the relatives, the travel, or the microscopic leftovers. We'll open up Doc's Thanksgiving Day gripe box when we come back. From Doc G, Sarah. the professor and everyone at DocG and the discussants on sabbatical. Happy holidays.
Whatever this season brings you, family, old friends, a little peace, or one more lively argument around the table, we hope you find something worth celebrating. Thank you for spending part of your year with us. We'll keep asking questions, telling stories, and finding the truth behind the talking points. Happy holidays from DocG and the discussants.
A headline tells you what happened. The interesting question, however, is why and what might happen next. On Doc G and the Discussance on sabbatical, we take on culture, politics, and policy with research, argument, and room for a little fun and mischief. New shows come your way Monday, Wednesday, and Friday. Find Doc G and the Discussance wherever you listen. and at docgandthediscusses .com. For the professor and Sarah, please remember the truth is more interesting than fiction and far more valuable than cliches or talking points.
Your car should start when you ask it to, it should stop when you need it to, and it should not make a new noise every Tuesday. At Blue Ridge Garage, we handle brakes, batteries, oil changes, tires and the mysterious sounds you've been ignoring for three months straight answers fair work no drama blue ridge garage keep the car lose the problem security isn't about reacting it's about knowing deep blue home security gives you full visibility doors windows motion all of it where you need it quiet system immediate alerts and no unnecessary noise Unless that noise matters.
Deep blue home security. You don't think about it because it's already handled. You bought the stuff, you wanted the stuff, and now you have absolutely nowhere to put the stuff. That's where Green Lawn Storage comes in. Clean units, easy access, plenty of room for furniture, tools, boxes, and everything else you swear you're going to use again someday. Green lawn storage. Your stuff needs a home, too. As veterans, we're no strangers to helping others. That's what we were taught. Service before self.
But we do have one question for the veterans listening. When was the last time you reached out for help? If you or someone you know needs resources, whether it's for stress, finances, employment, or mental health, don't wait. Reach out. Find more information at va .gov slash reach. That's va .gov slash reach. Brought to you by the United States Department of Veterans Affairs and the Ad Council. and send us your holiday gripes and letters to santa at doc g show studio at gmail .com we may read some of them on the show thank you for spending part of your year with us happy holidays from doc g and the discussants yeah we very much mean
Thanksgiving Gripes and Holiday Mayhem
that thank you so much for spending part of your year with us at doc g and the discussants we wish you a happy And healthy Thanksgiving and be, you know, make good choices, make good choices out there. There's a particular radio show host that locally that listen to her once in a while and she's big on... Make good choices. Make good choices. Make good choices. Yeah, it makes us want to strangle her. But I don't know how it came out of my mouth, but it did. We want to get back to the second half of the Jack Benny Thanksgiving special, but before that, I wanted to open up the old gripe box for some Thanksgiving -themed griping.
So let's pull the old gripe box over here and see what we can find inside. Oh, my word. Watch yourself around that box. You may have to get a tetanus shot. No way could we open up the old gripe box without the theme, so let's do that. What jumped out of the gripe box? Of course, it would have to be a turkey. Oh boy, isn't that clever. Did you drop something in there? The dinner is scheduled. This comes from Jan. She says dinner is scheduled for 2 PM at her house, but it somehow only goes off until around 6 30.
She says everyone stacks through the main event and she asks. There's always one guest who asks why the turkey is dry. She has also is the appetizer table and unauthorized competing restaurant and who should control the oven schedule. She said, should the host issue boarding passes for the dinner? I don't know Jan, sounds like Jan's got kind of a mess. I can't tell whether Jan's actually the person doing the hosting here or whether she's griping about somebody else that does the hosting. Are you sure that name isn't Yawn?
It could be, it might be, it's spelled J -A -N and it could be a guy. I was expecting it would be a lady but I think you're right, thank you. That sort of changed the context a little bit. So first, the gripe is, it's scheduled for two, but it doesn't really happen until 630. I don't know, let's go to Sarah. She probably has a little bit more idea of how to schedule a day in terms of the cooking part of it. What do you think? Is that a gripe or what? Sarah hit the wrong button on her chair and now she's slowly sinking below the level.
Of the table and doesn't know what to do about it. She's just looking at me like help me I don't know what it's Emotional support animal the bow is in in her lap So let me let me move her mic down to her a little bit or she may have to speak up a little bit So Sarah, what about this? What about this? I don't know. I I wouldn't wait that long. Why is it taking that long? Well, that's what we're asking you. What might be the problem? What's the problem? Are people not there? I don't know. No, I think they are.
Then it shouldn't take so long. Yeah, what Jan says, or Yawn, as the professor has suggested, the dinner's scheduled for 2 p .m. and somehow doesn't go off till 6 30. And again, I don't know if they're responsible for it going off late or what. Said everybody snacks through the main event. I think it sounds like a... Poor preparation to me. Yeah, and I can't tell whether Jan or Jan is responsible for this or what. And the thing is, who controls the oven schedule? Hell, I don't know what to tell Jan or Jan on this thing.
Should the host issue boarding passes for dinner? I don't know. I'm going to say this is Jan's problem and yawns problem or whatever. I don't really even understand. I do understand the gripe It's kind of like the day doesn't go the way it's supposed to but it's the holiday for God's sake so we're not really on a schedule if people are late if they show up late and they don't have their dent their their What they were supposed to bring ready and they're gonna have to cook it when they're there that might be a problem That might be the stove issue, I guess.
Well, usually, if you're taking something to a dinner, you usually have it fixed before you get there. Anyway, I'm not sure this is I maybe I don't understand the gripe correctly. That's just I don't really get it. I'm going to blow this one off. I don't think it's a deal because I'm never going to hurry to do anything on that day. I don't care what the schedule is. It sounds like maybe they're a little bit retentive in their attitude towards things. So I'm blowing that gripe off. Sorry, Yon or Jan.
I think it's your problem, not ours or anybody else's gripe too for the Thanksgiving gripes. This was kind of getting at what we talked about earlier Christmas before Thanksgiving is Richard's gripe says there's lights music and shopping promotions arrived before the turkey is even thawed Why not enjoy both is what I say to it I mean it now I've just quit fighting it so I did try to enjoy both the first Christmas Carol He says is heard in October Think I heard some Christmas care curls in October not you know in stores.
They were playing Christmas music the inflatable lawn displays You know that kind of stuff and those are you got to be careful with inflatables on your lawn because it looks like trash If you leave those things out, you can't you can't really leave them out. They're gonna blow down the street Even if they're not inflated on your lawn, you know, it looks like somebody blowing down the street. You know, I mean, I don't really care for them. I think they're great, you know, to set up for a for a little while because they're kind of cool for a little while.
But what's inflatable is those things that use car lots with their thrashing arms up in the air, a fan blowing up inside them. Those are kind of nice. Yeah. And occasionally you see one of those kind of blowing down the street. with one arm you know it's all flat in the gutter with just one arm still kind of flailing around him Let's see, let's look a little further into what he says here. Thanksgiving is a brief interruption of December, is what Richard claims. And he says the early decorating, you know, is just a little bit too much.
We said that a little earlier. I think it makes this holiday season not as special to celebrate Christmas immediately after things or immediately after Halloween. I think it, for me, I like the division, but I'm almost tired of fighting it. Anybody have any thoughts on this? I mean, is it, what do you think? I think you're not fighting it as smart. Yeah, I think that's finally what I got to because it kind of, I don't know, upset me just a little bit. It's like, what happened to Thanksgiving? One of the reasons why there's an actual Thanksgiving show now.
Just sit back with your triple scotch on shaved ice and don't fight it. Head out to my garage where I can visit my stable of exotic sports cars and exotic European super cars. Yeah, and don't fight it. I've kind of quit fighting it, but I do like Thanksgiving. It has no car that won't reach at least, very least, 250 miles an hour. Maybe 25 miles an hour. I think every car I own will go at least 25. I think that's a lot more likely. So before we close up the old gripe box, where we could get tetanus as well, and we'll end up the show today with the second half of the Jack Benny show.
I thought I'd ask everyone here what they're gripeful for, or gripeful. Gripeful or grateful? Gripeful or grateful? Sarah, let's start with you. What are you really grateful for? Oh, man. I hate these things. I don't guess I'm grateful for a whole lot. No, just kidding. I am thankful for my family and friends and for you. How sweet that was. Let's go to the professor where I think that our response won't be near so sweet. Professor, what are you thankful for? I just want to state that I think it's all in this not this isn't bad it's just a observation of reality but and i i'm going to attach your don't fight it comment to this it's all a meaningless frenetic thrash from cradle to grave so take the doc's advice and sit back and and don't worry what comes in what order whether it's christmas first them halloween or they're mixed or whatever sit back your triple scotch and Relax.
Visit your garage and enjoy your stable. Your long and elongated stable kind of formed in the old Spanish portico architecture of exotic European supercars. It gets a little worse. I can see it in my mind's eye. I'm grateful for Sarah and I'm grateful for the professor and I'm grateful for our time together that we've establish this show and we get to do this work together. I'm very grateful for that. I'm grateful for everyone's health here. I'm grateful that Bo shows up every once in a while even though we're not supposed to have an emotional support animal in the studio and I'm grateful for the Doc G audience and all that you've helped us with and the gripes that you send in even if some of them aren't as good as we'd like to hear.
We're always grateful for your gripes and any comments that you have. and we're grateful for your continued patronage of the show. Well, let's close up the old gripe box then. Everybody's learned to keep their fingers out of the way by this point. So that's going to about wrap it up. We'll be back on November the 30th. We wish you all a happy Thanksgiving and we'll leave you with the second half of the Jack Benny Thanksgiving show, part two. Now go out in the garage and feed the turkey. Okay, oh say boss, I meant to ask you something about that bird.
Are you sure it's a turkey? What do you mean, am I sure it's a turkey? Well, I went out in the garage a few minutes ago and she laid a egg as big as a cantaloupe As big as a cantaloupe? What are you talking about? Not only that, but every time I go in there she sticks her head in a bucket of sand What? Plus you bought an ostrich I bought an ostrich? That's right, she just ate the headlights off your car The headlights? How do you know? She had two Adam's apples and they were going down fast It's all your fault, Rochester.
You were with me when I went shopping for a turkey. Why did you let me buy an ostrich? I told you it was a pretty big bird for the money, but you know you. Well, I guess there's nothing we can do about it now. Isn't that awful? I got a polar bear in the guest room and an ostrich in the garage. And mice in the pantry. Let's move out. Now don't get panicky, Rochester. I'll be home in a few minutes. Meanwhile, call up the market and order a turkey. Okay. Goodbye. Goodbye. Oh, say boss. What? Have you changed your mind about using my twin brother Thursday night?
No, I haven't. Well, I'll figure out something. Goodbye. Wait a minute! Rochester! Rochester! Well, I'll be darned. What's the matter, Jack? Plenty. That big turkey I bought turned out to be an ostrich. Oh, boy. You're going to be lonesome on Thanksgiving. I am not. Now, Mary, don't worry. We're going to have a swell dinner. Play -filled. I wonder if you can eat an ostrich. I don't know.
This year, some folks are celebrating Thanksgiving on the 23rd of the month, others on the 30th. Well, either way, I'd like to offer a suggestion in regard to your holiday menu. For dinner, of course, there'll be plum pudding or pumpkin pie. But later on in the evening, when suppertime comes, bring the day's feasting to a fitting close with a truly out -of -the -ordinary dessert, a shimmering dish of golden lemon jello. Now there's really a luscious -looking dessert, ladies and gentlemen, a grand treat full of the ripe, tingling flavor of juicy lemons fresh from the tree and glowing with the warm color of sunshine.
And you can serve it in shapely molds, garnished with fruit, nuts, and maraschino cherries. Or it can be sliced into dainty cubes, tumbled into parfait glasses, and topped with snowy whipped cream. Either way, it adds up to a mighty slick dessert that will catch every eye and capture every taste. And that goes for all the rest of Jell -O's six delicious flavors. Strawberry, raspberry, cherry, orange, lemon, and lime. Jell -O, remember, is a light dessert. Just the thing to appeal after a heavy midday meal.
and it's quick and easy to make with and mother will appreciate it after working cooking a big Thanksgiving dinner so order genuine jello from your grocer tomorrow
last number of the seventh program in the current jello series and we will be with you again next Sunday night at the same time now don't forget Mary next Thursday night at my house for a real Thanksgiving dinner count me out Jack now wait a minute I'm not gonna serve that ostrich I'm gonna have a turkey oh yeah right yes Well, if I find a headlight in the dressing, watch out. Oh, don't worry. Good night, folks, and a happy Thanksgiving. Here's news. Every Tuesday night, The Aldrich Family is on the air, starring Ezra Stone as Henry Aldrich, that lovable, hard -luck kid.
Consult your local newspaper or radio guide for time and stations, and be sure to tune in on The Aldrich Family next Tuesday night. Bluebirds in the Moonlight is from Gulliver's Travels. This is a national broadcasting company. The discussion may be over, but there is plenty more waiting for you. Visit docgandthediscussants .com. Catch the latest episodes, meet the gang, suggest a future subject, leave a comment, and if something has truly managed to get under your skin, put it where it belongs.
Doc's gripe box. You can also support the show, explore sponsorship opportunities, and visit the shop. docgandthediscussants .com. Until next time. The Doctor is out.
Podbean