Who Is Comrade Piker? Hasan Piker, wealth, political influence, and the audience that came first.
This Episode
Who is Hasan Piker, and why do so many people spend hours watching his political streams? Doc G & The Discussants On Sabbatical examine his upbringing, his connection to The Young Turks, and the Twitch operation that turned him into a major voice in political media. We investigate his socialist politics and personal wealth, the controversial statements that have followed him into election campaigns, and the politicians who seek access to his audience. Then we return to a conclusion from our earlier communism series: for at least two generations, have education and culture helped socialize Americans toward a more collective understanding of society? New polling from Harvard and Gallup, and the rise of the Democratic Socialists of America, sharpen the question. Is Hasan Piker changing young minds, or speaking to an audience already prepared to listen?
Who Is Comrade Piker?
Right then, a quick warning before we begin. You may hear an opinion you don't agree with. Nothing will happen to you. There'll be no facilitator, no approved response, and absolutely no need to circle back. We'll simply carry on. Imagine how civilized. You're on sabbatical with Doc G and the discussants. Here's Doc G. Yeah, thanks a lot for joining us again on this Wednesday before the greatest hardest -working Thanksgiving show in show business which Our show is coming up just this Friday. Just a day friend.
You're fooling yourself ain't you? The hardest -working Thanksgiving show in show business show That's a lot of words. It's a lot of words and it's going to be a lot of show Yeah, so well, I don't think I want to participate in something like that Well, you better be here man because It starts at six o 'clock in the morning and we're expecting you to be here. Are we gonna be cutting up birds? Yeah, we will The whole story of how that came to be We're gonna turn a beautiful turkey into human fecal matter.
Yes, what you're saying? Yes that and some cranberries as well Anyway, it's gonna be fun just as the Halloween show was the best definitive Halloween show ever you've got a Thanksgiving show there's a a shortage of Thanksgiving shows and so we've got one of those things. Also remember to go to the website and send us your gripes because we've got a special edition of the gripe box on Thanksgiving. Thanksgiving gripes. And everybody's got those about a family member or food you don't like like you heard the professor just now sort of griping.
Send us your gripes so we can use them on the Thanksgiving show for the special edition. Also, subscribe to the newsletter. And Sarah, what should they do basically every single time? Like and subscribe. Like and subscribe. Today we're going to talk about somebody who may actually be a kingmaker at this point in the Democratic Party. I don't think that's actually the case. But he didn't hurt people like they thought. And who are we talking about? Mr. Hassan Hassan Dolin Piker. Online, it's Hassan Alibi, born in New Jersey in 1991, raised partly in Turkey, attended Rutgers University, nephew of jerk.
Ogre and founder of the Young Turks, or Cenk is, where Piker worked before building an independent career. He began streaming on Twitch in 2018 and shifted to full -time independent streaming in 2020. His hours -long broadcasts mix political analysis, news reactions, entertainment, and live audience chat. He calls himself a socialist and an anti -imperialist. A communist is not really a title that he uses for himself. It's a provocative characterization. He did say he'd like to see the United States adopt it.
Chinese style communistic government. Well, he certainly has adopted Chinese style dress and boy, isn't it sharp on him. We've seen him on a couple of talk shows with that and he turns up dressed like Chairman Mao here and there. Let's... And he dressed once like a French maid in a dress. It was very sexy. I saw that actually on the telly. Here's Piker's audience. If you could tell us about the scale Of your audience and how you think about who those people are like how many people are watching you?
uh, like can you talk a little bit about like Who the people are who are watching you and and how you kind of think about who your audience is? Yeah, so I uh, I do a yearly census Uh, and in that census i've noticed that like my audience is basically, uh grown up alongside myself, uh, so the demographics have remained like relatively stable. But the average Hasanabi head is what I call him or parasocialist is probably now in their mid to late 20s and is a white male. And many of them are college educated.
And the size of the audience itself, I mean, it's i don't know what the full magnitude is what the full uh what the full size looks like but i mean i've consistently been one of the top content creators on the platform twitch uh and uh and probably am the largest uh leftist content creator in north america so so since they've kind of grown up with you and they're in their late 20s like presumably now like i mean a lot of them have Have jobs like do they have time to when are they kind of watching the stream?
I would imagine if you're in your early 20s You probably have some more time that you can kind of pop on to the stream and and see what's going on Are you picking up on uh any sort of changing? viewership now that your audience has kind of grown up with you and they're older and Presumably like have some stuff to do during the day other than just kind of watch you on on your stream Yeah, I mean I have Amazon delivery drivers who have me in their ear while they're driving throughout the day. So I think like for a lot of people they consume my content in a way that like our parents generation consumed like AM radio conservative talk radio.
So they just kind of have it on and throughout the day I just go through the news piece by piece with no repeats. So They just have it on as an unending eight -hour podcast. Yeah, unending eight -hour podcast. That's a long, long time to be on the air, so to speak. September 2026 Guardian Profile observed a stream with about 25 ,000... to about 30 ,000 concurrent viewers. Piker separately claimed 300 ,000 to 500 ,000 unique viewers per hour. Now, that's an estimate. It's not a audited measure. So, you know, can we distinguish about how big that audience is?
It's a big audience, any way you slice it, and it's made him very wealthy. his efforts here in March 2026 Semit for interview piker compared all day streaming to the companionship of traditional talk radio and I think that that's probably a fair characterization of this who is consuming it well he told us They're in their early to mid 20s to early 30s, and they're generally male. And we saw during this last election that a lot of those guys voted for the Democrat socialist candidates. Delivery drivers with piker in their ears all day long makes me wonder how long they're going to keep their jobs.
It's hard for me to imagine in this country that this is the sort of content that young men are consuming. I don't know. Professor, what do you think? I think it's more stick it to the man crap. I think it's more, well, I don't see any opening for me. I don't see a possibility. What does Hassan have to say? What can I do? And when I hear college -educated anymore, at least regarding a four -year degree, I think, personally, me, I think stupid and uneducated. I know that's controversial. I think they're an immature group that I wish didn't have the stature and power, that age bracket, until they grow a little older and accrue a little more wisdom.
I think if you're listening to a songpiker, the whole thing is dangerous for the country. but that's just what i think well i think that that's is sort of a problem and very dangerous because this is a movement that we've seen worldwide it is a movement that takes full advantage of jealousy and of envy and it also allows you to transfer your shortcomings the things that you haven't done to prepare for life And believe me, as a high school teacher, as a person who ran schools, I watched students come to school day after day and do as little as they possibly could.
just to get out the door with a high school diploma. And it's become the important thing is they had an earbud in and they were listening to Hassan. And now they have even more reason to be upset about their circumstances because they've been given carte blanche to feel upset about it instead of let's say going to a career and technical education situation where I would learn how to weld. AI isn't going to weld anything where they would learn how to let's say do HVAC work again AI is not going to come in and fix your air conditioning or your car it's the white -collar jobs that are going to have it hardest with AI and so you know they're going to have to start rethinking about how they're going to prepare for life but there's a lot of folks out there who've done nothing to prepare for life and there.
pinning their hopes on candidates. people in power that are going to take money out of one group of people's pockets and they're going to transfer it to you because you're special and you should have this consideration even though you have done nothing nothing to prepare yourself for life whatsoever these are the same people who think that i should be able to go to a fast food franchise get a job and have and make a living doing that that if i have any job whatsoever that that should rep represent a living in this country.
It has never been that way. Those jobs were reserved for children, for high school students to learn how to work, to work when they could, those sorts of things. Now, kids won't really do those jobs because they're too busy doing sports and their parents don't really want them to work. How in the world do they expect to? Make car payments house payments those sorts of things even if the left got they wanted let's let's give them 50 bucks an hour That's not gonna cut it either Not the kind of living that they think that they should have so have you noticed that nothing ever improves Everything is just slowly sinking.
Well, I think that for many people it improves Beyond belief those who've prepared their selves for the economy are doing very very well And I'm talking about the same people we talked about a little with people with a CTE degree We're talking about two years a lot of times you can prepare for that in high school if you've prepared yourself You don't really like row Mike row and he's trade school endorsement. Maybe he's correct Yeah, well, you know, he's kind of late to the party in my estimation.
I mean that's been going on a long long time But the argument has been, well, we have emphasized college beyond trade schools and beyond, you know, shop classes and things like that. I think that there's a lot of that that's true. But both things, both things are a path to prosperity if you stick on them. Now, if you just show up and you expect to be given things. like a lot of these folks are they expect that they should just have a dignified living no matter what you are and no matter what you've done that is the free rider problem in socialism and communism and that i just get what i get because i'm me and i should have it So says Mr. Piker and many of his ilks.
Sarah, you're looking at me like you've got something to say or... No, I don't really. I just don't understand why these guys like Piker, he has all this money. He hates capitalism. He makes money hand over fist. And yet wants everybody else to give their money away, but he didn't want to give his away. Well, that's I wonder how many people he's got living in his front yard. Probably none. Well, I think it should be Doc G in the discussion. I don't want to live in his fucking front yard. I don't want to be anywhere within the same block with him because I hate people that.
that trade in hate and jealousy. And this is what it is. This is what communism is. It's hate and jealousy. And it is a very strong emotion. I've advised many people to say, never ever underestimate this because it is much easier to blame your problems on somebody else. And you hear it. in the strangest places. I've heard it from people on the right very lately. If you really checked your philosophy here, do you mean what you say? Because if you do, you're piker light, you're DSA light, you're Democrat light.
I'll assign a couple of those comments to the vice president not very long ago. Journalist, he's an entertainer. Is he an advocate or an organizer? Why does an audience spend hours with one political personality? And how does this model differ from television or radio? A critic of capitalism who has become wealthy inside of it, to Sarah's point. A contradiction or is this consistency? You're listening to Doc G and the Discussance. The discussion continues in just a moment. While we take a break, go to Doc G and the Discussants .com.
Meet the Discussants, catch another episode, support the show, visit the shop, or tell your favorite cast member exactly what's on your mind. Doc G and the Discussants, on sabbatical, back after this. Tells you what happened. The interesting question, however, is why and what might happen next. On Doc G and the Discussance on sabbatical, we take on culture, politics, and policy with research, argument, and room for a little fun and mischief. New shows come your way Monday, Wednesday, and Friday.
Find Doc G and the Discussance wherever you listen. and at docgandthediscusses .com. For the professor and Sarah, please remember, the truth is more interesting than fiction and far more valuable than cliches or talking points. You bought the stuff, you wanted the stuff, and now you have absolutely nowhere to put the stuff. That's where Green Lawn Storage comes in. Clean units, easy access, plenty of room for furniture, tools, boxes, and everything else you swear you're going to use again someday.
Green lawn storage. Your stuff needs a home too. When your heating or cooling system quits, you don't want a sales pitch. You want it fixed. Call Hartman Heating and Cooling. Our experienced technicians service all major brands and offer repair, replacement, seasonal maintenance, and indoor air quality solutions for homes and businesses. And with 24 -hour emergency service, Hartman is there when you need us most. Call today and ask about our seasonal system check. Hartman Heating and Cooling. Comfort you can count on.
Quality still matters. From premium mattresses and living room furniture to dining sets and home accents, Oak & Iron focuses on comfort, durability, and timeless design without the pressure and confusion of the big box stores. Visit Oak & Iron Home Center and see the difference for yourself. This is Ravi Shankar. As I travel around the world, I feel that the young people are searching. for the means with which to attain peace, happiness and spiritual awareness. Why not get high on life itself without using any drugs?
You young ones, you have the elixir of life. You don't need hard drugs to make your life more meaningful.
Funny, our story becomes obvious once everybody else starts saying it. You heard Doc G and the Discussants working it out weeks ago. They'll tell you what they think and they'll tell you why. The truth is more interesting than fiction and far more valuable than cliches or talking points back to the hardest working podcast in
The Champagne Socialist's $2.7M Home
show business. Indeed the hardest working podcast in show business. Not sitting around and watching somebody else talk and then talk over the top of them. It's not what we're about. We can do a little research and then we talk about what's actually going on and this is what Mr. Piker said recently about his uh champagne socialist tendencies did you always want to be a champagne socialist um yes you once said this let the streets soak in red capitalist blood how was the oscar parties this year it was weird jeff bezos was there terrifying a lot shorter than i thought he would be so that's what he thought of bezos who's short you know mr hiker Let the streets soak in red capitalist blood.
Is Bezos shorter than Abdul -Hel Saeed? I don't know, let's find out. Sarah's going to look that up for us and we can get some good statistics on that. In October 2026, in an interview with Z -Way, Piker discussed a California house reportedly valued at about 2 .7 million and said it was financed with a mortgage. He was asked whether he wanted to be his champagne socialist and he answered affirmatively in a comedic exchange. He argued that housing should be available to everyone and described his own business as a cooperative arrangement with equal say and equal pay.
Those labor arrangements are his claims, not independently audited findings. Boy, I think that that could be something that maybe the administration could do before their lame duck term comes to an end. I think Champagne Socialist sounds like it could have been a song from the Atlanta Rhythm section. They've always been accused of these things when people come up with great ideas about what they're going to do with their money and that housing should be afforded to everyone. uh... you know they're they're they're very generous with other people's money very generous he's making some money I'm the first one who's going to apologize to him if he's got a little encampment on his grounds at the 2 .7 million dollar house.
Now that's probably not, I think he's in L .A. So if it's 2 .7 million in L .A. it's probably not a huge house. Oh, that's a check. A million isn't going to get you much there, but another million will get you something kind of nice. How many sheds does he have on his property where he's got homeless people living where he can put into practice What he preaches. What he preaches. Why is he not, and he may be, and I'm happy to apologize if he in fact is doing this, how many small homes, tiny homes, I think is what they like to call them, are on his property right now with utilities.
A cardboard carton and dumpsters. I'm sure he doesn't have any cardboard carton and dumpsters on the property. That would be unsightly. That's okay on your public Street that's fine or your yard or your yard, but not in his I'm asking again How many sheds does he have on his property tiny homes nice neat little properties? That he's providing housing for other people with his money How many right now? Not how many are you going to go and establish in a week? So you can say you've done it. How many are you doing right now?
Oh, he won't even do that. And how many people? I hope you're not pointing out Hassan's hypocrisy. Really trying not to. I really hope that I'm wrong. I hope that I'm wrong. I'm hoping for a change that one of these people that want to spend your money on other people is actually spending their money on this constituency. for all of them. That same thing can be said for all of them. Every one of them. When they showed up in Martha's Vineyard... Oh yeah. Let's get them out of here. That was funny.
We talked about that years ago. Years ago. I said the best thing that could happen would be to drop some of these folks off in... Nancy Pelosi's neighborhood, in Joe Biden's neighborhood, in Chuck Schumer's neighborhood. Let's see how long they stay. They didn't even stay very long in Martha's Vineyard. And guess who they blamed for that? They blamed DeSantis for that because he sent them there. It's all okay. If they're in your neighborhood, but it they're not okay in my they were just there about 28 hours, right?
I don't think they were there that I mean, they kind of were didn't they welcome them on a porch. I mean, they I think they gave them like some kind of little party there for about and then the Greyhounds showed up and said, you know, you'd be so much more comfortable, more comfortable outside of of our little Enclave and off they went. I where did they send? I can't remember but they didn't stay there very long and boy that was really the test Carlton. Yeah Well, yeah, on the taxpayer dime, because no one else is going to pay for that, that's for certain.
Again, I like our experiment. I think that we need to go and live on the premises of one thing, because all we want is a better life, just a better life. And we should be able to live in the gated compounds of these people who are espousing these things. I know, you know, All the money that Doc G has supposedly it'd be hard for me to find a better life But I think don't forget his extensive stable of exotic European supercars Yeah, I think I could probably find a better life at the pool house of Bruce Springsteen.
I think I probably could But how about the pool house of mr. Piker? I think he may have a nicer pool house than my house. Oh, so I'm in the cabana right now. Do you want me to call him? Yeah, and so I'm just saying all I'm looking for is a better life, and I'm entitled to housing and I Think we're entitled to his house Not his house everybody's entitled to my property my private property, but not to his and I'm sure that'll be the last property that's ever confiscated by anybody so the wealthy socialist house business ideology we've been talking about here socialism addresses ownership labor and distribution personal wealth does not alone establish.
or disprove ideological consistency. But when you're driving a Porsche around and you're walking around in double -breasted suits and attending pool parties, when your brethren out there that you're trying to get housing for all, I mean, couldn't he sell that Porsche and buy somebody a shed to live on? There's a homeless man sleeping in your Porsche.
I wish that would be you, Professor, so we could get that on film to see how long you would last in the Porsche. The working Porsche pool party language, I don't know, maybe it's a little harsh. Am I being unfair to Mr. Piker here? Am I? No. Yes. Well, then I think we should just leave it right there then because I guess I've stepped across a line that I shouldn't have stepped across. But I mean, come on. This is this is ridiculous. And it is, again, appealing to the lowest common denominator in human language or in human existence, jealousy and envy, because Jeff Bezos has more money.
Somehow he screwed people. I don't have it. He took my money. That's just crap and they've got a lot of kids believing this apparently Amazon drivers who work for Bezos In their ears all day long speaking of which Bezos is taller So give us the stats on that, would you? Bezos is like 5 '8", 5 '9", and El -Sayed is like 5 '5", 5 '6". 5 '5"? Okay, there you go. There it is. If he's 5 '5", he's got to be walking around with lifts in his shoes. Oh, yeah. You heard it here first. No, I already got rid of that.
I moved on. So, Sarah, how tall are you? Five -three. Five -three. Yeah. El -Sayed has you by two inches. That's if he's reporting the right... I think I could take him. Yeah. I think you could take him. I think I could. So we've talked about the Porsche Drive. We've talked about the mouse suits. We've talked about, you know, this kingmaker status that he seems to now sort of have, at least within the DSA. I think what we're going to talk about next is some of his actual comments, and we're going to let his comments out of his mouth speak for themselves.
Now, we're going to do that in the next segment, and I do want to warn people. This man is profane. About every third word is going to be a ugly cuss word. an ugly, cursing situation from start to finish. Oh god, gee, quit being so pretty to just say it. I'm not, because that's just not what we offer here. It's not where we are. if we if we get emotional about something and a word comes out that's that's one thing you're going to see the difference in what i guess passes for entertainment with the antifa crowd and i uh maintain that they now learn to vote they were in the streets burning yeah they learned how to vote they listened we told them hey listen if you've got a grievance Don't burn, don't loot, don't cause civil unrest.
What you should do is, if you don't like the situation, learn how to vote. Well, guess what? They learned how. And now they're voting and they're voting their candidates in. So, did we teach them the wrong thing? No, we didn't. We taught them the right thing. Well, if we can... Presumed to have taught them anything. Yeah, if they don't get their way, that's what's going to happen anyway. So his most disputed words has followed him into electoral politics and we're going to play those words for you.
That's coming up next. Shall I cover my ears? Yeah, you should. I just can't wait. I want to hear that. You're listening to Doc G and the discussants.
We'll give the Discussents a moment to regroup. In the meantime, visit docgandthediscussents .com. Episodes, the shop, ways to support the show, and of course, Doc's Bright Box. Do make proper use of it. Doc G and the Discussents, on sabbatical. We'll be right back. Every successful show has great sponsors. If you'd like to introduce your business to our audience, we'd like you to consider our tremendous sponsorship opportunities. Choose from general admission, mezzanine, front row floor, backstage pass, or executive producer.
Every sponsorship includes recognition on the show, founding sponsor status, preferred advertising rates, and additional benefits based on your sponsorship level. or simply looking for a better place to manage your everyday finances, our local team is here to help. With convenient online and mobile banking, competitive lending options, and people you can actually talk to, Ozark Regional Bank combines modern banking with hometown service. Stop by one of our convenient locations or learn more today.
Ozark Regional Bank. Your car should start when you ask it to, it should stop when you need it to, and it should not make a new noise every Tuesday. At Blue Ridge Garage, we handle brakes, batteries, oil changes, tires, and the mysterious sounds you've been ignoring for three months. Straight answers, fair work, no drama, Blue Ridge Garage. Keep the car, lose the problem. Don't you wish your life came with a warning app? That dog does not want to be petted. Just a little heads up before something bad happens.
Move your coffee cup away from your computer. So you can have more control. Stop, you're texting your boss by mistake. Uh oh. Well, life doesn't always give you time to change the outcome. But pre -diabetes does. With early diagnosis and a few healthy changes, like managing your weight, getting active, stopping smoking, and eating healthier, you can stop pre -diabetes before it leads to type 2 diabetes. It's easy to learn your risk. Take the one -minute test today at DoIHavePreDiabetes .org. Warning.
The cap is loose on that catam. Ugh. Don't wait. You have the power to change the outcome. Visit doihabprediabetes .org today. That's doihabprediabetes .org. Brought to you by the Ad Council and its prediabetes awareness partners. If you have need for an emotional support animal, well, you're in the wrong place. You're on sabbatical with Doc G and the discussants at the intersection of policy, politics, and culture. Have a question for your favorite discussant? Well, please visit us. on the World Wide Web at the discusses .com the doctor is in Doc G
When Radical Rhetoric Meets Politics
Sarah and the professor we're going to take about a week off here shortly for Thanksgiving yeah that was going to be after the hardest -working Thanksgiving show in showbiz show so we're not leaving him with nothing we're going to you know give them a fantastic show to last them all the week long because everybody's going to be you know full of turkey they're gonna be full of turkey except the professor he's not going to because it has a face and a mother I'm not going to eat a bird he's not gonna eat a bird he's not he's not doing that so it's not everybody that's gonna have turkey I know the professor's not we are Well, it's not our favorite thing either.
We usually do ham instead, but ham has a face. No, we do ham at Christmas. That comes from one of nature's garbage collectors. So what are we having anyway? Turkey. We're having turkey. I'm provided a turkey from work. Yeah, you should be provided a turkey from work. Because I work for turkeys? No, because they're rich. SOBs that owe you a turkey at least. They owe you a turkey so it should be not just a turkey but cranberry and a place to eat that and cook that. That's what they owe you because you're you, you're special and your hiney is shinier and better than anybody else's.
During an August 2019 broadcast, oh one more thing. Okay. Get your gripes in for the greatest Thanksgiving show, the hardest -working Thanksgiving show. Gripes? We have a special gripe box. Thanksgiving gripes? Yes, get them in. Hey man, I want to hear this X -rated language you promoted that before the break from Hassan. We're waiting on that. We're on the edge of our seats waiting for all the profanity. Notice my technique in holding listeners. Let's see. I'm going to start cussing here shortly.
Yeah, then that'll blow my hold of listeners. Let's say during a August 2019 broadcast criticizing American foreign policy and representative Dan Crenshaw. Now he is the guy who, Texas, I believe, eyepatch. I think. Oh yeah. Yes. I remember that guy. I think I've seen him on TV before. Yes. Piker said America deserved 9 -11. He later called the wording inappropriate and said he intended to argue about blowback from United States actions in the Middle East. Now that's a centerpiece of this postmodern philosophy that they're running around doing.
The United States is the culprit and we deserve what we get because We export violence and so violence is going to be visited on us instead of celebrating United States might and wins overseas. It's all seen as unnecessary and everything is our fault. That's their take on these things. Again, I'm going to warn the studio audience. If you have children and you don't want them to hear profanity, and I mean top grade profanity, usher them out of the room or you can turn it off for a little while or whatever but I'm going to warn you again we warned you before the break I'm going to play Mr. Piker and some of his comments and this is probably the worst thing that we've ever played on the show and I think it sounds like a angry eighth grader is what I think We'll see what you think.
I wanted you to hear this in his own words. Do you not want to be unfair to the man? No, what's happening? We fucking totally brought it on ourselves, dude. Holy shit. We did. We fucking did. In a video game, whatever, hypothetically, politically. We fucking did, man. We did. Holy shit. Holy fucking shit. Look at the way that this dipshit is running his fucking mouth. Justifying genocide right now. Like how is this how is anything I'm saying controversial like we fucking fund the people who did 9 -eleven still to this day Donald Trump literally went on national television and said they buy ten million dollars with ten billion dollars with the weapons So if they chop chop chop an American law legal permanent resident, it's okay.
Can you imagine listening to this guy in your headphones? all day long. I mean, that is the moral equivalency at its best. There's really no intellectual weight behind it. What it is is let me cuss at the top of my lungs. And I guess that's attractive to young men. That titillated to me. It was stimulating. I guess so. But this, to me, it sounds like some of the eighth graders that I used to be around. If you were standing at the bus stop, how they would actually, you know, talk to each other. And that's the speed of our electorate.
He wanted to compare himself a little bit earlier to, I guess, people on the right, like Rush Limbaugh, who were doing, you know, talk radio. I don't think so. Not even close. Not even close. Man. So in 2026, PolitiFact reviewed an attack on a Michigan candidate, Abdul El Saeed, and distinguished Piker's statement from positions the candidate actually endorsed. Piker's Israel -related commentary has attracted accusations of anti -Semitism and extremism, including from the Anti -Defamation League.
Piker disputes that characterization and distinguishes opposition to Zionism from hostility towards Jewish people. That's a little dance that he and El Saeed and that silk is getting very good at. And if you really pin them down, this is what they do. Well, this has nothing to do with the price of groceries or gas. It has nothing to do with putting money in your pocket. What are we even talking about this for? I don't want to talk about that anymore. You know, that kind of... Let me duck out of this crap and go back to where my consultants told me I should be.
I'm going to just... talk about this. September 2026 Guardian profile and an October 29th Washington Post reporting described his involvement with the Democratic candidates and the risks of association. It didn't really look like anybody paid the price for the association, which was very interesting to me. I think I said on a show not too long ago, I didn't know why a particular candidate would be within a block. It was Ilhan Omar. why they would be within a block of Mr. Piker. Apparently their internal polls were showing that's just okay.
It's just okay to be around him. Zoran Mondani once again appears on the program. is among the political figures connected to the broader discussion. His audience may offer attention and organization energy while opponents reuse his controversies in campaign advertising." Well, that's probably his biggest controversy that we played just a second ago, and he later disavowed those comments as he really didn't mean them. Now, let's... take a look at that. Do you think Mr. Piker meant what he said? Let's go to the professor first on this.
You heard the comments, and I know you were anxiously awaiting these comments, or at least you said so. What do you think? Do you think he meant them, or what? Well, that's a tough one. I think he was on the meaning side of indifference. I think he expresses more passion that he actually harbors for the sake, for commercialization. I think he's a, I don't think, how that's difficult, it's a fine line in there. I think he believes what he said, but I don't think he's as passionate as he expressed it.
I think he gets carried away in it, meaning he likes the match, he gets the burner going, then it just kind of explodes within him and then... That way he keeps the Amazon drivers who have him in their ear all day long as they make deliveries excited. I think it's hyperbolic but I so it's I don't think he's as invested emotionally as the finished product would seem to indicate although I think when he into this and the rhetoric begins I think it escalates to where at that point he in a way is that invested but it there's a fine psychological line there between how deep is this in his soul and then how it comes out ultimately once he gets rolling verbally.
I think I'm going to go with that, doctor. If you remember Debbie Dingle right before the election who took her her husband's seat over in the House of Representatives and now has been there quite some time. She was really afraid of his influence and basically said at a opportunity that she didn't want to hear anymore about Mr. Piker. This is just a distraction. We heard James Carville completely disavowed and said this guy has no place in the party along with El -Sayed. They're singing a different tune now.
And this is who they are endorsing. Who we just played a little earlier. That is the sort of entertainment. Let me rephrase this as the professor might know. That's what I call entertainment. This incessant hardcore cursing on the radio to a audience that I guess just can't do any better than this sort of commentary?
It's inciting, it's titillating and inciting, and it makes the listener feel good in a way. My next question is, have they not heard this sort of language before? Maybe it's just how they speak to each other. I think it's common now. I think talking this way is pretty normal, and again, Normal changes all the time. Oh, yeah But it's just another indication of Idiocracy. Yes. I swear I was getting to this is maybe the best example of Idiocracy we have put on the program that this guy is making this huge living and this is his best One of his best moments that people have pointed out time and time again.
Well, did Piker create this political appetite to find an audience prepared for over decades? I think he's again speaking to the choir. You're going to get the Doc G line on why this is so appealing to at least a couple generations now. When we come back, you're listening to Doc G and the Discussance on sabbatical. Some of our best ideas come from the people listening. If you have a question, a comment, a show idea, or maybe someone you'd like us to interview, we'd love to hear from you. Just visit docgandthediscussants .com, click contact, and choose your favorite discussant from the drop down menu and send us your message.
Your questions, comments, or suggestions might even become part of a future episode. Thanks for listening. We appreciate it. The leaves look beautiful right up until they cover the driveway. And the snow is charming until you have somewhere you really need to be. Hi, Doc G here for Four Seasons Leaf and Snow Removal. They handle both situations. They clear the yard in the fall, the walk in the winter, and the one stubborn patch you thought would melt by noon. Four Seasons Leaf and Snow Removal. Enjoy the seasons.
They'll handle what they leave behind. Accidents happen. Getting your vehicle repaired shouldn't add to the headache. At Premier Collision and Auto Body, we work with all major insurance companies and handle everything from minor dents and paint repair to major collision damage. Our technicians use modern repair equipment, computerized paint matching, and manufacturer -recommended repair procedures to help get your vehicle back where it belongs, on the road. Free estimates are available Monday through Friday.
Premier Collision and Auto Body. Quality repairs, straight answers, Smokey the Bear. After 80 years of learning his wildfire prevention tips, Smokey Bear lives within us all. Learn more at SmokeyBear .com. And remember, only you can prevent wildfires. Brought to you by the USDA Forest Service or State Forestry and the Ad Council. Every grand plan needs a road. At Good Intentions Paving Company, we build it before anyone asks where it goes. We offer smooth surfaces, attractive signs, and a ribbon cutting at your convenience.
Questions about the destination? Those belong to the next committee. Good Intentions, your paving company. When somebody says what could possibly go wrong, we're already laying asphalt. Right then, break's over. If you spent it circling back, unpacking your feelings, or searching for a safe space, do try to keep up. The rest of us are getting back to the show. And while you're there, have a look at docandthediscosence .com. Episodes, the gripe box and plenty more trouble waiting for you. You're on sabbatical with Doc G and the Discussants.
The truth is more interesting than fiction and far more valuable than cliches or talking points. Back to it.
Who Gets to Define Your Freedom?
I think we could compare the Good Intentions Paving Company to the DSA. good intentions. And that's about all it takes for the youth of America is to say, you're special. Your heiny is more special and shiny than anyone else's. And for that reason, you should have a home and plenty of food to eat, even if you just play video games all day. I mean, there's I mean, there's no criteria here. It's everyone is entitled to the things that they would like to have courtesy of these evil
imperialist, capitalist that we need to rid the country of. There's a lot of people who believe that. Speaking of the evil founding of the country, coming up on Friday, once again, let me promote the hardest working Thanksgiving show in show business show. Get your gripes in, go to the website and make sure that you put your gripe in so we can Read what you think about Thanksgiving in your heart of hearts So let's return to the show's earlier three -part communism series when we came on the air.
We talked about the allegory of the cave Plato's allegory of the cave and How people are grown up and socialized and what they hear? in what they believe is part and parcel of their world view. I have said many many times on the show now that our young people have been socialized now for at least two generations, I think longer than that, to believe that the country was founded illegitimately and that We owe apology to many many groups worldwide and that we are the problem in the world No one else and if you look at textbooks, it's very subtle.
It's Apologies basically for manifest destiny for America's great victories somehow or another it was unfair and Instead of being proud of our victories, which a strong people will do and should do It's a weak people that then decides that our history is all wrong so basically what's going to happen is our victories are going to be turned into defeats by those who just do so with their mouth guys like this communist criticizing the greatness of the country and something else. Capitalism has made the country what it is.
For the first time in human history, people were allowed to keep the fruits of their labor. You didn't have to give it to a king, a potentate. Now you have to pay taxes or you're going to be in trouble. Let these communists be in charge a little while longer and see how much they decide to take and then let's see how hard people want to work when they know that everything that they earn is basically someone else's property what they'll do is they just won't work and they'll take whatever. the collective decides to give them, as the presser has detailed many, many times.
And some will put a gun to their head. Well, some will put a gun maybe to someone else's head because true Americans aren't going to put up with it. They're not going to put up with having their property confiscated by those who basically want to disempower one side, one political side, to empower their constituents. to then gain more power and that is communism in a nutshell besides that it is based in envy and jealousy and rage by those who either refuse to participate or have had bad luck and will not get up again some people just when they get knocked down that's where they're going to stay they are perfect candidates for uh...
communism and i think we've found quite a few of them out there uh... so we've we described it we've said early on one of the reasons why the judgment was made to go ahead make those shows is because we saw this coming i've seen it coming for a long long time and when we saw some of these d s a candidates uh... making moves fairly convinced that we were seeing the beginning of a movement that we all may regret and now we're deep into it with candidates being elected across the political spectrum at the federal level, at the state level, and at the local level and all the enthusiasm and energy is there and it goes back to Occupy Wall Street, a movement that really bothered me, especially in this country.
Whether changes in education and culture help explain how receptive people are to these policies remains to be proven by research. But if we understand what Education's power is in society and then we look at some of the people who have put themselves in education especially critical theorists of all kinds it's not hard to see where these things are coming from you know across at least two generations now emphasis on equity group identity we've been about individualism in this country and whenever you hear one of these people say we should all Be very careful about what comes out of their mouth next, because this is part of the group identity that they are really trying to inculcate.
Structural explanations for inequality and collective responsibility may have made some social claims more familiar. Some of those social claims are embedded in DEI policies. Some of those claims are that... the united states is inherently racist white people are inherently racist and have there's nothing they can do about that Further, there's nothing that those on the margins can do about this because it's structural. Nothing can be done. That is just Marxism repackaged in a way that the American people can swallow because there's always been issues around race.
They had a real tough time selling it economically, but in the terms of race they found fertile ground. The Democratic Socialists of America have expanded their membership and electoral presence for certain we've seen this, that shows organizing momentum and not exactly why it occurred. I am offering a theory of why this has occurred, and what I'm saying is that they're speaking to the choir, and this is the reason why. And so, to combat it, if anyone is interested, I've talked to lots of people, politicians, about this, and they sort of looked at me sometimes like I had two heads, like, what are you?
What are you talking about? Well, this is what I've been talking about for quite some time. Let's go to the discussants. So monopolize. I'm not sure how much people are going to fight. I mean, that's that's what concerns me is I'm not sure how much people are really going to fight the issues. How many people have just at this point given up and go, there's nothing I can do about it? That's not the American people, not the true American soul. I think that we've led a lot of people in the country now who are from countries who have this tradition.
And so this is going to look very, very familiar to them. And I think that's another reason why the border has been laid wide open. Another episode that we have detailed. And here they come again. We've already heard of the caravans getting organized. I don't know why they wouldn't now they have a friendly governor in Texas and Friendly friendly senator and that's the front door to them. Who's going to stop them now? I say that those caravans are going to end up being extremely energetic in a very short period of time Let's go to the professor professor.
What do you think? It all looks somewhat hopeless to me I don't think anything dramatic, there's not going to be any kind of explosion or anything hyperbolic happen all of a sudden. But as I said earlier, it seems like everything is sinking gradually, maybe like the Titanic went down. It took many hours for it to go down. It seems like too many people and too many people looking for some ticket to ride and they see that in the Hassan Pikers and his ilk. And even though it's unreal, They don't know that.
I mean, after all, they're college grads. I don't have to worry about the midterms anymore. I've already graduated. You know, that kind of thing. It doesn't look good to me. It doesn't look good long run. I mean, hopefully my lifespan will get me out of it because it gets too horrible. But that's kind of the way I see it. I'm not trying to be a pessimist. I'm just trying to be a realist. Well, I see it kind of the other way. I think this is an opportunity to really show that these these philosophies and this government style will how are you going to get enough people on that within that mode of thinking on your side they'll they'll see it they will see it you think they will see it i mean it may take a while you have more confidence in the masses than i do i think doc i think i agree in your ability to see it it quotes see it i seem like they don't see it until it's Too late.
Well, think about this. They were elected on affordability and their life becoming better. Now they're going to have this opportunity that they can they can blame Trump because he will veto things. And my prediction is he will have no legislative agenda. So they'll hang it around his neck. See, we told you it's unaffordable and it's even more unaffordable now because this old orange idiot is still in the White House elect us. But. It doesn't mean that they can deliver a better life. They cannot deliver a better life to people.
They just cannot. They do not have the policy to do so. They just need to go back and forth, back and forth, back and forth. That was the way it was designed. never controlled by one person or one political party, but it's swinging now very far left. And then we have a lot of Republicans who, in my mind, are Democrat light, including the vice president and some of his ilk. I've got some candidates in mind that I'd much rather see. You know, I want to be very fair to Mr. Piker here. This is how he tried to slither out of those comments.
So you said America deserves Did you mean that? No, obviously not, especially considering the fact that while that is a very viral quote that is going around currently, if those people were at least. even remotely charitable or cared about the actual truth of what I was talking about. They would understand that within context, I was simply referencing the fact that all of the foreign policy decisions and our arming of insurgent groups in the region and our efforts in destabilizing the Middle East have a direct consequence, a boomerang effect rather, if you will, in causing 9 -11.
Of course, every part of what I advocate for is against violence. I abhor violence, I think it's awful. And as a matter of fact, I was very frustrated with the fact that Dan Crenshaw, a person who four times voted nay on bills that would stop arming Saudi Arabia. He voted no four times on those bills, would turn around and talk about the necessity for endless violence. And that this simply was happening because these people This simply was happening because these people just hated us. They hated us because they hate us, I'm paraphrasing.
But I thought that was awful. I thought that that was horrific. And in that moment, I thought, at the very least, I was saying that you can draw a direct line basically, that it was a consequence of all the things that we have done in the region. This is not a controversial thing to say, which is precisely why I followed up by saying, why are you guys getting upset at me? There's a live chat, there's a back and forth conversation on Twitch, for those of you who are unfamiliar, said, why are you getting upset at me?
Nothing I'm saying is controversial, implying that I didn't even understand immediately why what I was saying was so outside of the bounds of reason, considering that Hillary Clinton has had a similar. and correct opinion on this, talking about how we did fund Al -Qaeda. Okay. And Noam Chomsky and numerous other academics on both sides of the political spectrum. So when you're talking about one of the cause of 9 -11 being American foreign policy. It's not just Chomsky, Donald Trump has said similar things.
Donald Trump has said that as well. I understand that, I understand that. But you understand now, and not just now, but you understood fairly soon after you said it, that saying Americans deserve 9 -11 is a completely different statement and one that's wrong. No, I didn't say Americans deserve 9 -11, I said America deserves 9 -11. Right, but that's still wrong. Well, maybe you can chalk it up to English being my second language or whatever you wanna chalk it up to. English is his second language.
There you go. There's the out right there. There's the side door. Yeah, and now also notice his uncle. That was Unger trying to rehabilitate him a little bit. an avenue for him to make an apology, which he he didn't make. And it was just all semantics. I said that America deserved it, not Americans. Well, I but something about the letter S. Yeah, you're right. And the and the earlier comment that he just abhors violence abhors it. I was told that he'd like to see the streets soaked in my capitalist blood just a little earlier now.
I ask again, do you think that Hassan Piker meant what he said the first time around? I think he meant it. I think that's what is in his heart. I think that he would like, and not only did he think that we had it coming, he was glad to see it happen. Instead of... Being mature enough to understand that countries worldwide will get into conflicts and they must to protect their interests and that the other side is not going to be happy about that what happens and that in fact they may counter attack.
It's a week people. that uh... it can be talked out of their greatness and people like piker and the critical theorists that come up with these theories and they're only limited by their stupid imaginations this guy sounds like an eighth -grader to me i don't know whether it sounds like that to you piker needs to be in one of the world trade center buildings after the plane hit he needs to be above where the plane hit where he can't go down maybe space with a decision of Now do I want to burn alive or shall I just jump out the window and plummet to my death?
Well, the difference is they're Americans, not America. Oh, I missed that distinction. My goodness, such a nuanced individual. I think he really reasons like an eighth grader, and I suppose he's talking to an audience largely composed of folks that reason like an eighth grader. It's a puzzle to me. why it would get to be that popular, but apparently it has. But at the same time, it's not a puzzle to me. We've been socialized to believe that the United States should get whatever it has coming to it because it's evil, of course.
That's not our message here at Doc G and the Discussants. America is the greatest country on the face of the globe and probably the best country that will ever be conceived going forward. We are here to support you and we're not giving up. We're here to fight to the bloody end. You're listening to Doc G and the discussions for Sarah and the Professor. We'll see you next time. And so we reach the end, not the end of the argument. Obviously that would be terribly convenient. There are still facts to examine, conclusions to question, and more than a few cliches awaiting retirement.
Before you disappear, visit Doc G. dot g and the discussance dot com meet the cast find the latest episode suggest a future subject leave us a comment now or if something has particularly annoyed you place it directly into doc's gripe box you can also support the show explore the sponsorship opportunities share and naturally do a little shopping there is really quite a lot going on over there dot g and the discussance dot com until we reconvene Keep thinking for yourself, the doctor is out.
Podbean